EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q38 · Reasoning

Year2022
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ38
SubjectReasoning

Two Statements followed by four Conclusions are given below. You have to take the Statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from the commonly known facts. Read all the Conclusions and then decide which of the given Conclusions logically follows/follow from the Statements, disregarding the commonly known facts :
Statement-1 : All pens are books.
Statement-2 : No chair is a pen.
Conclusion-I : All chairs are books.
Conclusion-II : Some chairs are pens.
Conclusion-III : All books are chairs.
Conclusion-IV : No chair is a book.
Which one of the following is correct?

  1. aOnly Conclusion-I
  2. bOnly Conclusion-II
  3. cBoth Conclusion-III and Conclusion-IV
  4. dNone of the Conclusions follows
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) None of the Conclusions follows

None of the conclusions logically follows across all valid Venn diagram configurations.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Conclusion-I states All chairs are books.
  • While chairs can be inside books without touching pens, chairs can also lie completely outside books.
  • Since it is not true in all valid Venn diagrams, Conclusion-I does not follow.
✗ Option (b)
  • Conclusion-II states Some chairs are pens.
  • This directly contradicts Statement-2 which explicitly asserts No chair is a pen.
  • Hence, Conclusion-II is definitely false and does not follow.
✗ Option (c)
  • Conclusion-III states All books are chairs, which is false because the pen portion of books can never be chairs.
  • Conclusion-IV states No chair is a book, which is only a possibility because chairs can partially or fully overlap books.
  • Neither Conclusion-III nor Conclusion-IV is guaranteed to be true.
✓ Option (d)
  • No single conclusion is definitely true in all possible Venn diagram representations.
  • Conclusion-I and Conclusion-IV form an All and No pair, which are contraries and do not make a valid Either-Or complementary pair.
  • Therefore, none of the conclusions follows.

Concept to know

  • Syllogisms rely on strict logical deduction where a conclusion must hold true in all possible Venn diagram interpretations.
  • Statement-1 (All pens are books) means the set of pens is a subset of the set of books.
  • Statement-2 (No chair is a pen) means the set of chairs and the set of pens have zero overlap.
  • The relationship between chairs and books is not fully determined; chairs can be outside books, partially overlapping books, or inside books while staying away from pens.
  • A complementary pair for an Either-Or case requires specific combinations like Some and No (I and E) or All and Some Not (A and O).
  • The combination of All and No (A and E) consists of contraries that can both be false at the same time, so they do not form an Either-Or relationship.

Related facts for revision

  • Standard conversion rules of categorical propositions where All A are B converts validly only to Some B are A.
  • Conditions required to establish an Either-Or complementary pair between two invalid conclusions.
  • Evaluating possibility cases versus definitive conclusions in categorical syllogisms.
  • Understanding distributed versus undistributed middle terms in multi-statement logic.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to draw all possible Venn diagram configurations and distinguish between definitive logical conclusions and mere possibilities.

Trap: Candidates often confuse the combination of All chairs are books and No chair is a book as an Either-Or pair, missing the fact that both can be false simultaneously when Some chairs are books and Some chairs are not books.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.