EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q25 · Data Sufficiency

Year2022
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ25
SubjectData Sufficiency

Consider the Question and two Statements given below :
Question : Is Z brother of X?
Statement-1 : X is a brother of Y and Y is a brother of Z.
Statement-2 : X, Y and Z are siblings.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the Question and the Statements?

  1. aStatement-1 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
  2. bStatement-2 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
  3. cBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are sufficient to answer the Question
  4. dBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are not sufficient to answer the Question
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Both Statement-1 and Statement-2 are not sufficient to answer the Question

Neither statement provides the gender of Z, leaving it unknown whether Z is a brother (male) or a sister (female) to X.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Statement 1 establishes that X is male and Y is male.
  • It does not reveal the gender of Z, who could be either male (brother) or female (sister).
  • Hence, Statement 1 alone is insufficient to answer the question.
✗ Option (b)
  • Statement 2 states that X, Y, and Z are siblings.
  • It gives no information about the gender of any individual, including Z.
  • Hence, Statement 2 alone is insufficient to answer the question.
✗ Option (c)
  • Combining both statements confirms that X and Y are male siblings of Z.
  • However, the gender of Z remains unspecified as Z could be male or female.
  • Since a definitive Yes or No cannot be reached, both statements combined are insufficient.
✓ Option (d)
  • Even after combining both statements, Z can be either a male sibling (brother) or a female sibling (sister).
  • To answer Is Z brother of X?, the exact gender of Z must be explicitly determined.
  • Therefore, both Statement-1 and Statement-2 together are not sufficient to answer the question.

Concept to know

  • Data Sufficiency rules require a statement to yield a unique, unambiguous answer, whether that answer is a definite Yes or a definite No.
  • In Blood Relation problems, a person's gender cannot be assumed from names or sibling ties unless explicitly stated or directly deducible.
  • The term sibling refers to brothers or sisters collectively and does not specify male or female gender.
  • A relation like Y is a brother of Z specifies the gender of Y as male, but leaves the gender of Z completely undetermined.
  • To prove Z is the brother of X, two conditions must be met: Z and X must share the same parents, and Z must be male.

Related facts for revision

  • Gender-blind relation traps: Terms like sibling, spouse, cousin, child, and parent do not specify gender.
  • Definite No as a sufficient answer: In Data Sufficiency, if data proves Z is definitely female, the answer to Is Z brother of X? is a conclusive No, which counts as SUFFICIENT.
  • Family Tree diagrams: Using standard symbols such as plus for male, minus for female, and horizontal lines for siblings prevents gender confusion during solving.
  • Common CSAT Data Sufficiency variations: Questions testing order, seating arrangements, and ages often use incomplete gender or positional data as distractor traps.
How UPSC tests this

Evaluating logical completeness and gender determination rules in blood relation data sufficiency questions.

Trap: Assuming Z is male simply because X and Y are brothers, or assuming that a conclusive answer of No means data is insufficient.

More Data Sufficiency PYQs

All Data Sufficiency questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.