UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q11 · Comprehension
"In simple matters like shoe-making, we think only a specially trained person will serve our purpose, but in politics, we presume that everyone who knows how to get votes knows how to administer a State. When we are ill, we call for a trained physician, whose degree is a guarantee of specific preparation and technical competence—we do not ask for the handsomest physician, or the most eloquent one : well then, when the whole State is ill should we not look for the service and guidance of the wisest and the best?"
Which one of the following statements best reflects the message of the author of the passage?
- aWe assume that in a democracy, any politician is qualified to administer a State.
- bPoliticians should be selected from those trained in administration.
- cWe need to devise a method of barring incompetence from public office.
- dAs voters select their administrators, the eligibility of politicians to administer a State cannot be questioned.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The author uses analogies of shoemaking and medicine to argue that governance requires technical competence and wisdom, implying that society must establish mechanisms to prevent incompetent individuals from holding public office.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- This option describes the current flawed practice that the author is actively criticizing rather than the main takeaway.
- The author does not support this assumption but highlights it as a societal failure.
- The author uses professional analogies to advocate for wisdom and technical competence in general.
- The passage does not mandate that politicians must come specifically from formal administrative training institutes.
- The author argues through analogy that just as technical competence is required for medical care, governance requires the wisest and best individuals.
- This directly implies the need to prevent unqualified and incompetent persons from occupying public office.
- This option explicitly contradicts the author's primary line of reasoning.
- The author's entire argument is centered on questioning the eligibility of candidates who merely know how to win votes.
Concept to know
- Distinguishing between descriptive statements representing the criticized status quo and normative statements representing the author's message.
- Understanding classical political analogies, specifically Plato's Craft Analogy from the Republic, which compares governance to specialized skills like medicine.
- Identifying implicit conclusions from rhetorical questions, where the final question functions as an assertive recommendation for selecting competent leaders.
- Avoiding literal over-interpretation of analogies, ensuring that specific examples like shoe-making or medicine are understood as metaphors for general competence.
- Evaluating candidate options against the primary motive of the passage, which seeks to reform political selection by barring incompetence.
Related facts for revision
- Central Theme vs Implied Message: Central theme summarizes the subject matter, whereas implied message addresses the underlying recommendation or imperative.
- Analogy-Based Reasoning: Question types where arguments rely on structural similarities between everyday skills and complex systems.
- Assumption Identification: Recognizing unstated premises, such as the assumption that vote-gathering ability does not equal governance expertise.
- Distractor Elimination Techniques: Rejecting options that restate the problem rather than the solution proposed by the author.
Ability to extract the central message and normative conclusion of an analogy-based philosophical passage.
Trap: Candidates often choose Option (a) because it reflects a line in the text, failing to realize the author mentions it as a flawed practice to be corrected.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.