UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q19 · Data Sufficiency
Consider the Question and two Statements given below :
Question : Is x an integer?
Statement-1 : x / 3 is not an integer.
Statement-2 : 3x is an integer.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the Question and the Statements?
- aStatement-1 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
- bStatement-2 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
- cBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are sufficient to answer the Question
- dBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are not sufficient to answer the Question
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Even after combining both statements, x can be an integer such as 1 or a non-integer fraction such as 1/3, so a unique answer cannot be determined.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Testing Statement-1 alone where x/3 is not an integer.
- If x = 1, then x/3 = 1/3 (not an integer), and x is an integer (Answer: Yes).
- If x = 1/2, then x/3 = 1/6 (not an integer), and x is not an integer (Answer: No).
- Since we get both Yes and No outcomes, Statement-1 alone is not sufficient.
- Testing Statement-2 alone where 3x is an integer.
- If x = 1, then 3x = 3 (an integer), and x is an integer (Answer: Yes).
- If x = 1/3, then 3x = 1 (an integer), and x is not an integer (Answer: No).
- Since we get both Yes and No outcomes, Statement-2 alone is not sufficient.
- Combining Statement-1 and Statement-2: x/3 is not an integer AND 3x is an integer.
- If x = 1, x/3 = 1/3 (not an integer) and 3x = 3 (an integer); here x is an integer (Answer: Yes).
- If x = 1/3, x/3 = 1/9 (not an integer) and 3x = 1 (an integer); here x is not an integer (Answer: No).
- Since two contradictory answers are still possible, combining both statements is insufficient.
- Statement-1 alone allows multiple conflicting cases (x = 1 vs x = 1/2).
- Statement-2 alone allows multiple conflicting cases (x = 1 vs x = 1/3).
- Combining both statements still leaves conflicting cases (x = 1 vs x = 1/3), making option (d) correct.
Concept to know
- Data sufficiency questions require determining whether given information leads to a unique, definite answer (Yes or No).
- A statement is insufficient if choosing different valid test values produces conflicting Yes and No answers.
- An integer belongs to the set {... -3, -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, 3 ...}, whereas fractions like 1/3 or 1/2 are non-integers.
- To evaluate statements involving real numbers, always test integers, proper fractions, and zero to uncover edge cases.
- If combining statements still permits both integer and non-integer values for the variable, the combination remains insufficient.
Related facts for revision
- In number system data sufficiency questions, testing simple unit fractions like 1/k is a reliable way to find counterexamples.
- A statement is sufficient in a Yes/No question ONLY if it yields a consistent YES or a consistent NO in every case.
- Always check if a variable is specified as a real number, rational number, or integer, as constraints change the outcome.
- Systematic substitution of extreme and fractional values eliminates tempting incorrect options quickly.
Testing number properties and applying systematic counterexample methods in Data Sufficiency questions.
Trap: Assuming that 3x being an integer forces x to be an integer, forgetting that x could be a fraction like 1/3 whose denominator cancels out with 3.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.