UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q37 · Data Sufficiency
Consider the Question and two Statements given below in respect of three cities P, Q and R in a State :
Question : How far is city P from city Q?
Statement-1 : City Q is 18 km from city R.
Statement-2 : City P is 43 km from city R.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the Question and the Statements?
- aStatement-1 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
- bStatement-2 alone is sufficient to answer the Question
- cBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are sufficient to answer the Question
- dBoth Statement-1 and Statement-2 are not sufficient to answer the Question
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Even when combining both statements, the lack of directional or angular arrangement between cities P, Q, and R leaves the distance PQ anywhere between 25 km and 61 km.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement-1 specifies the distance between city Q and city R as 18 km (QR = 18 km).
- It provides no information about city P or its position relative to Q or R.
- Hence, Statement-1 alone is insufficient to answer the question.
- Statement-2 specifies the distance between city P and city R as 43 km (PR = 43 km).
- It provides no information about city Q or its position relative to P or R.
- Hence, Statement-2 alone is insufficient to answer the question.
- Combining both statements gives QR = 18 km and PR = 43 km.
- If P, Q, and R are collinear with Q between P and R, then PQ = 43 - 18 = 25 km.
- If P, Q, and R are collinear with R between P and Q, then PQ = 43 + 18 = 61 km.
- If P, Q, and R form a triangle, PQ can take any real value strictly between 25 km and 61 km depending on the angle at R.
- Because a single unique distance PQ cannot be determined, both statements together are insufficient.
- Statement-1 alone gives only QR = 18 km, which is insufficient.
- Statement-2 alone gives only PR = 43 km, which is insufficient.
- Combining both statements fails to yield a unique distance because the relative directions or collinearity of P, Q, and R are unspecified.
- Therefore, Both Statement-1 and Statement-2 are not sufficient to answer the Question.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency evaluates whether the given statements provide enough information to determine a single, unique numeric answer.
- The distance between any two points in a 2D plane depends on both their relative distances to a third reference point and their spatial directions or angles.
- By the Triangle Inequality theorem, for any three non-collinear points forming a triangle PQR, the distance PQ must satisfy 43 - 18 < PQ < 43 + 18, meaning 25 km < PQ < 61 km.
- If points are collinear, PQ equals either PR - QR = 25 km or PR + QR = 61 km, depending on the relative positioning of the points.
- A set of data sufficiency statements is declared sufficient only if it eliminates all ambiguity and yields one exact answer.
Related facts for revision
- Collinearity requirement: Knowing that points lie on a straight line is not enough unless their exact linear sequence (order of points) is also specified.
- Directional vectors: If directions or bearings are provided alongside distances, exact distances can be solved using the Law of Cosines.
- Triangle Inequality Range: For given side lengths a and b, the unknown side c ranges within |a - b| <= c <= a + b.
- Sufficiency vs Calculation: In CSAT data sufficiency, proving that multiple valid answers exist is sufficient to eliminate an option without calculating every intermediate value.
Testing geometric reasoning and spatial awareness to recognize when missing directional data creates multiple valid distance solutions.
Trap: Assuming the three cities automatically lie on a straight line in a fixed order and choosing option (c) after calculating 43 - 18 = 25 km or 43 + 18 = 61 km.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.