UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q3 · Comprehension
Unless the forces and tendencies which are responsible for destroying the country's environment are checked in the near future and afforestation of denuded areas is taken up on a massive scale, the harshness of the climatic conditions and soil erosion by wind and water will increase to such an extent that agriculture, which is the mainstay of our people, will gradually become impossible. The desert countries of the world and our own desert areas in Rajasthan are a grim reminder of the consequences of large-scale deforestation. Pockets of desert-like landscape are now appearing in other parts of the country including the Sutlej-Ganga Plains and the Deccan Plateau. Where only a few decades back there used to be lush green forests with perennial streams and springs, there is only brown earth, bare of vegetation, without any water in the streams and springs except in the rainy season.
According to the passage given above, deforestation and denudation will ultimately lead to which of the following?
1. Depletion of soil resource
2. Shortage of land for the common man
3. Lack of water for cultivation
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
- a1 and 2 only
- b2 and 3 only
- c1 and 3 only
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly mentions soil erosion (depletion of soil resource) and dry streams/springs affecting agriculture (lack of water for cultivation), but makes no mention of shortage of land for the common man.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The text directly states that soil erosion by wind and water will increase due to deforestation and denudation.
- Soil erosion directly leads to the degradation and depletion of topsoil resources needed for plant growth.
- The passage discusses the degradation of land quality and environmental decay, not the physical shortage or availability of land for human settlement or individual ownership.
- Extrapolating land quality degradation to mean a literal shortage of land for the common man goes beyond the strict scope of the provided text.
- The author points out that streams and springs now lack water except in the rainy season, leading to agriculture becoming impossible.
- This highlights a severe seasonal and perennial lack of water necessary for sustaining cultivation.
Concept to know
- Strict adherence to passage scope: Only facts, direct implications, and logical consequences supported by the text should be treated as correct.
- Distinction between land quality and land availability: Pay careful attention to word meanings; environmental degradation destroys soil fertility, which is distinct from physical land availability or land rights.
- Elimination of broad socio-economic extrapolations: Statements bringing in outside general knowledge like demographic pressure or human land shortages must be rejected if unmentioned.
- Mapping cause-and-effect relationships: Map cause-and-effect relationships presented in the text, such as deforestation leading to soil erosion and stream drying.
Related facts for revision
- Direct consequence questions: These test whether the candidate can identify explicit outcomes stated by the author.
- Crucial assumption questions: These require identifying unstated premises essential for the argument's conclusion to hold true.
- Best reflects the main idea: Questions asking for the core message require synthesizing the main argument without over-focusing on minor examples.
- Logical inference questions: Inference questions permit logical deductions strictly derived from the text without introducing external assumptions.
Ability to strictly analyze explicit text details and avoid introducing external socio-economic generalizations.
Trap: Candidates often choose option (d) assuming environmental degradation automatically reduces usable land, leading to general land shortage, even though the text never discusses land allocation or availability.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.