EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q41 · Comprehension

Year2022
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ41
SubjectComprehension

For two or three generations past, ever-increasing numbers of individuals have been living as workers merely, not as human beings. An excessive amount of labour is rule today in every circle of society, with the result that man's spiritual element cannot thrive. He finds it very difficult to spend his little leisure in serious activities. He does not want to think; or he cannot even if he wants to. He seeks not self-improvement, but entertainment which would enable him to be mentally idle and to forget his usual activities. Therefore, the so-called culture of our age is dependant more on cinema than on theatre, more on newspapers, magazines and crime stories than on serious literature.

The passage is based on the idea that

  1. aman should not work hard
  2. bthe great evil of our age is overstrain
  3. cman cannot think well
  4. dman cannot care for his spiritual welfare
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) the great evil of our age is overstrain

The core premise of the passage is that excessive labor or overstrain in modern society prevents individuals from spiritual growth, deep thinking, and meaningful leisure.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • The passage criticizes excessive labor and lack of leisure, but it does not prescribe that human beings should refrain from working hard altogether.
  • Prescribing a total avoidance of hard work is an extreme prescription not supported by the author.
✓ Option (b)
  • The opening lines identify an excessive amount of labour as a widespread rule that forces individuals to live merely as workers rather than human beings.
  • All subsequent observations regarding spiritual decline, inability to think, and reliance on light entertainment stem directly from this root cause of overstrain.
✗ Option (c)
  • Inability to think deeply is described as a consequence of mental fatigue and overwork, not the foundational idea of the passage.
  • The author attributes cognitive exhaustion to the overwhelming burden of daily work.
✗ Option (d)
  • Neglect of spiritual element is highlighted as a downstream effect of excessive labour rather than the main premise itself.
  • The text shows that spirituality cannot thrive because man is overburdened by overstrain.

Concept to know

  • Central Idea Identification: Identify the primary cause or thesis around which all secondary observations and consequences are structured in the passage.
  • Cause versus Effect Distinction: Distinguish between the root cause (overstrain and excessive labor) and the resulting symptoms (lack of spiritual growth, reliance on entertainment, inability to think).
  • Tone and Scope Assessment: Avoid choosing options with extreme normative statements, such as complete prohibition of hard work, which go beyond the author's intent.
  • Structural Flow Mapping: Trace how the text moves from a core premise in the first two sentences to specific illustrative consequences in the remaining sentences.

Related facts for revision

  • Main Idea vs Implication Questions: Main idea questions seek the foundational theme, whereas implication questions require deriving unstated logical consequences.
  • Assumption Questions: Focus on the unstated underlying belief required for the argument to hold true, distinct from direct summaries.
  • Extreme Word Elimination: Watch out for extreme qualifiers like never, always, or complete prohibition that alter the scope of the passage.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to distinguish the central underlying cause or premise from its secondary effects and consequences.

Trap: Options (c) and (d) describe real effects mentioned in the passage, tempting candidates to pick symptoms rather than the root cause.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.