UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q69 · Numeracy
There are two containers X and Y. X contains 100 ml of milk and Y contains 100 ml of water. 20 ml of milk from X is transferred to Y. After mixing well, 20 ml of the mixture in Y is transferred back to X. If m denotes the proportion of milk in X and n denotes the proportion of water in Y, then which one of the following is correct?
- am = n
- bm > n
- cm < n
- dCannot be determined due to insufficient data
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Both containers return to a total volume of 100 ml each, resulting in the proportion of milk in X (5/6) being exactly equal to the proportion of water in Y (5/6).
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Transferring 20 ml milk from X to Y makes Y contain 100 ml water and 20 ml milk (total 120 ml, milk ratio 1/6, water ratio 5/6).
- Transferring 20 ml mixture from Y to X moves (20 x 1/6) = 10/3 ml milk and (20 x 5/6) = 50/3 ml water back to X.
- Final milk in X is 80 + 10/3 = 250/3 ml out of 100 ml (m = 5/6), and final water in Y is 100 - 50/3 = 250/3 ml out of 100 ml (n = 5/6), giving m = n.
- The calculated value of m is 5/6 (0.833) and n is 5/6 (0.833).
- Since 5/6 is equal to 5/6, the statement m > n is false.
- The calculated value of m is 5/6 (0.833) and n is 5/6 (0.833).
- Since 5/6 is equal to 5/6, the statement m < n is false.
- Sufficient parameters including volumes and transfer quantities are provided.
- Exact numerical values for m and n can be uniquely determined.
Concept to know
- Step-by-step volumetric tracking: track the precise volume of each pure component after every transfer step.
- Uniform mixture removal rule: when a volume of mixture is removed, its components leave in exact proportion to their presence in the container.
- Conservation of volume and symmetry: if equal initial total volumes are restored after exchanges, the volume of water displaced into X must equal the volume of milk remaining in Y.
- Proportion calculation: proportion of a component is defined as component volume divided by total container mixture volume.
- Universal equal swap theorem: whenever equal final volumes are maintained between two pure liquid containers after cross-transfers, the proportion of original liquid 1 in container 1 always equals the proportion of original liquid 2 in container 2.
Related facts for revision
- Repeated removal formula: remaining pure liquid = Original Volume x (1 - transfer volume / total volume)^n.
- Alligation technique for finding missing concentrations after mixing two solutions.
- Conservation logic shortcut: if final total volumes are equal, water in X equals milk in Y, saving calculation time.
- Multi-step mixture transfers with unequal replacement volumes.
Testing volumetric analysis, mixture transfer tracking, and recognition of algebraic symmetry in conservation problems.
Trap: Assuming the 20 ml mixture returned from Y contains pure milk or 10 ml of each, leading to wrong manual steps instead of using the volume symmetry principle.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.