EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q69 · Numeracy

Year2022
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ69
SubjectNumeracy

There are two containers X and Y. X contains 100 ml of milk and Y contains 100 ml of water. 20 ml of milk from X is transferred to Y. After mixing well, 20 ml of the mixture in Y is transferred back to X. If m denotes the proportion of milk in X and n denotes the proportion of water in Y, then which one of the following is correct?

  1. am = n
  2. bm > n
  3. cm < n
  4. dCannot be determined due to insufficient data
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) m = n

Both containers return to a total volume of 100 ml each, resulting in the proportion of milk in X (5/6) being exactly equal to the proportion of water in Y (5/6).

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Option (a)
  • Transferring 20 ml milk from X to Y makes Y contain 100 ml water and 20 ml milk (total 120 ml, milk ratio 1/6, water ratio 5/6).
  • Transferring 20 ml mixture from Y to X moves (20 x 1/6) = 10/3 ml milk and (20 x 5/6) = 50/3 ml water back to X.
  • Final milk in X is 80 + 10/3 = 250/3 ml out of 100 ml (m = 5/6), and final water in Y is 100 - 50/3 = 250/3 ml out of 100 ml (n = 5/6), giving m = n.
✗ Option (b)
  • The calculated value of m is 5/6 (0.833) and n is 5/6 (0.833).
  • Since 5/6 is equal to 5/6, the statement m > n is false.
✗ Option (c)
  • The calculated value of m is 5/6 (0.833) and n is 5/6 (0.833).
  • Since 5/6 is equal to 5/6, the statement m < n is false.
✗ Option (d)
  • Sufficient parameters including volumes and transfer quantities are provided.
  • Exact numerical values for m and n can be uniquely determined.

Concept to know

  • Step-by-step volumetric tracking: track the precise volume of each pure component after every transfer step.
  • Uniform mixture removal rule: when a volume of mixture is removed, its components leave in exact proportion to their presence in the container.
  • Conservation of volume and symmetry: if equal initial total volumes are restored after exchanges, the volume of water displaced into X must equal the volume of milk remaining in Y.
  • Proportion calculation: proportion of a component is defined as component volume divided by total container mixture volume.
  • Universal equal swap theorem: whenever equal final volumes are maintained between two pure liquid containers after cross-transfers, the proportion of original liquid 1 in container 1 always equals the proportion of original liquid 2 in container 2.

Related facts for revision

  • Repeated removal formula: remaining pure liquid = Original Volume x (1 - transfer volume / total volume)^n.
  • Alligation technique for finding missing concentrations after mixing two solutions.
  • Conservation logic shortcut: if final total volumes are equal, water in X equals milk in Y, saving calculation time.
  • Multi-step mixture transfers with unequal replacement volumes.
How UPSC tests this

Testing volumetric analysis, mixture transfer tracking, and recognition of algebraic symmetry in conservation problems.

Trap: Assuming the 20 ml mixture returned from Y contains pure milk or 10 ml of each, leading to wrong manual steps instead of using the volume symmetry principle.

More Numeracy PYQs

All Numeracy questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.