UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q13 · Comprehension
The poverty line is quite unsatisfactory when it comes to grasping the extent of poverty in India. It is not only because of its extremely narrow definition of 'who is poor' and the debatable methodology used to count the poor, but also because of a more fundamental assumption underlying it. It exclusively relies on the notion of poverty as insufficient income or insufficient purchasing power. One can better categorize it by calling it income poverty. If poverty is ultimately about deprivations affecting human well-being, then income poverty is only one aspect of it. Poverty of a life, in our view, lies not merely in the impoverished state in which the person actually lives, but also in the lack of real opportunity given by social constraints as well as personal circumstances—to choose other types of living. Even the relevance of low incomes, meagre possessions, and other aspects of what are standardly seen as economic poverty relate ultimately to their role in curtailing capabilities, i.e., their role in severely restricting the choices people have to lead variable and valued lives.
Why is income poverty only one measure of counting the 'poor'?
- aIt talks of only one kind of deprivation ignoring all others.
- bOther deprivations in a human life have nothing to do with lack of purchasing power.
- cIncome poverty is not a permanent condition, it changes from time to time.
- dIncome poverty restricts human choices only at a point of time.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly states that income poverty focuses exclusively on insufficient income or purchasing power, which represents only one aspect of human deprivations while ignoring others such as lack of opportunities and capabilities.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage notes that income poverty exclusively relies on the notion of insufficient income or purchasing power.
- It explicitly highlights that income poverty is only one aspect of deprivations affecting human well-being.
- Thus, it addresses only one specific type of deprivation while ignoring broader deprivations such as social constraints and restricted choices.
- The passage does not claim that other deprivations have zero connection to purchasing power.
- On the contrary, it mentions that low income and meagre possessions relate directly to curtailing human capabilities.
- The extreme assertion that other deprivations have nothing to do with purchasing power distorts the passage text.
- The passage nowhere discusses whether income poverty is a permanent or temporary condition over time.
- It focuses on the conceptual definition of poverty rather than its temporal duration or variability.
- The passage does not state or imply that choice restriction occurs only at a specific point of time.
- This temporal restriction is completely absent from the author's argument.
Concept to know
- Identify the core argument: Locate the author's central claim regarding why a single indicator is insufficient to capture multidimensional poverty.
- Strict textual matching: Select options that reflect exact explicit statements from the text rather than external real-world assumptions.
- Eliminate extreme phrasing: Be cautious of options containing absolute terms like have nothing to do with or only at a point of time unless verbatim supported.
- Distinguish scope from duration: Differentiate between arguments dealing with the scope of a definition versus those dealing with time or permanence.
Related facts for revision
- Direct retrieval vs inference questions in CSAT reading comprehension.
- Identifying distractor patterns such as extreme claims, out-of-scope facts, and logical distortions.
- Underlying conceptual framework: Amartya Sen's Capability Approach versus traditional income-based poverty measures.
Ability to identify explicit central premises in a passage and eliminate distorted or overly extreme options.
Trap: Candidates often choose option (b) assuming non-income deprivations are independent of money, but option (b) uses an unsupported extreme statement.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.