UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q57 · Numeracy
Year2022
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ57
SubjectNumeracy
24 men and 12 women can do a piece of work in 30 days. In how many days can 12 men and 24 women do the same piece of work?
- a30 days
- bMore than 30 days
- cLess than 30 days or more than 30 days
- dData is inadequate to draw any conclusion
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Data is inadequate to draw any conclusion
The relative work efficiency between a man and a woman is not specified, making it impossible to calculate the required number of days.
Statement-by-statement analysis
✗ Option (a)
- This option assumes that 1 man's work efficiency equals 1 woman's work efficiency, making 24 men plus 12 women equal to 12 men plus 24 women.
- Since relative efficiency is not specified in the question, assuming equal efficiency is mathematically incorrect.
✗ Option (b)
- This option assumes that a man is more efficient than a woman, which would make 12 men and 24 women less efficient than 24 men and 12 women.
- Without information on whether a man is more or less efficient than a woman, concluding that it takes more than 30 days is unjustified.
✗ Option (c)
- This option excludes the case of taking exactly 30 days, which happens if a man and a woman have equal efficiency.
- Selecting a vague range without knowing the efficiency ratio remains a guess rather than a mathematical conclusion.
✓ Option (d)
- Let m be the daily work rate of one man and w be the daily work rate of one woman.
- Total work equals 30 × (24m + 12w), and the time required for 12 men and 24 women is 30 × (24m + 12w) / (12m + 24w) = 30 × (2m + w) / (m + 2w).
- Because the ratio of m to w is unknown, this value can be equal to, greater than, or less than 30 days, so the data is inadequate.
Concept to know
- In Time and Work problems involving multiple types of workers, solving for time requires knowing their relative work efficiencies.
- Total Work W is calculated as Time taken multiplied by the sum of individual daily work rates.
- To find the time taken by a new combination of workers, the new rate must either be a direct multiple of the original rate or individual efficiency ratios must be known.
- If the unknown daily rates cannot be expressed as a fixed multiple of the given daily rates, the system has infinitely many solutions.
- Underdetermined systems of linear equations lead to inadequate data in quantitative aptitude questions.
Related facts for revision
- Proportional Grouping: If the target group is half of the original group, time taken will be exactly double.
- OR Statements: Statements like A men OR B women can complete work in D days directly yield the efficiency ratio A × m = B × w.
- Data Sufficiency Rule: Count independent linear equations against unknown variables before attempting calculations.
How UPSC tests this
Testing the candidate's understanding of linear equation systems and preventing unwarranted assumptions about variable efficiencies.
Trap: Candidates often intuitively assume men are more efficient than women (choosing b) or assume equal efficiency (choosing a) without checking variable sufficiency.
← Previous · Q56There are eight equidistant points on a circle. How many right-angled…Next · Q58 →What is the remainder when 91 x 92 x 93 x 94 x 95 x 96 x 97 x 98 x 99 is…
More Numeracy PYQs
How many words can one form by shuffling the letters of the word QUEUE, if Q is always followed by U? The words thus formed need not necessarily have any meaning.
See the answer & explanation →
X, Y and Z jump forward 4', 6' and 5', respectively. At 8 AM, they all land on mark 199'. How many times will they all land on the same mark (need not be at the same moment) between mark 195' and 1000', if all of them cross mark…
See the answer & explanation →
A toy T jumps forward or backward. In each forward jump, it moves 5' forward whereas in each backward jump, it moves 2' backward. If in 31 jumps, T moves exactly 15' forward, then what is the difference of the number of forward…
See the answer & explanation →
If 10^m × 1000 × n = 75^25 × 25^32 × 32^75, where n is not divisible by 10, then the value of m is
See the answer & explanation →Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.