UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q39 · Reasoning
Three Statements followed by three Conclusions are given below. You have to take the Statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from the commonly known facts. Read all the Conclusions and then decide which of the given Conclusions logically follows/follow from the Statements, disregarding the commonly known facts :
Statement-1 : Some doctors are teachers.
Statement-2 : All teachers are engineers.
Statement-3 : All engineers are scientists.
Conclusion-I : Some scientists are doctors.
Conclusion-II : All engineers are doctors.
Conclusion-III : Some engineers are doctors.
Which one of the following is correct?
- aOnly Conclusion-I
- bOnly Conclusion-II
- cBoth Conclusion-I and Conclusion-III
- dBoth Conclusion-I and Conclusion-II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Conclusions I and III logically follow from the given statements, whereas Conclusion II does not necessarily follow.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- This option claims only Conclusion I follows, but Conclusion III also validly follows.
- Since some doctors are teachers and all teachers are engineers, some doctors must be engineers, making Conclusion III true.
- This option claims only Conclusion II follows, which is incorrect.
- All engineers being doctors cannot be definitely derived, as we only know a partial overlap between doctors and teachers or engineers.
- Conclusion I follows because doctors overlap with teachers, who are a subset of engineers, who are in turn a subset of scientists.
- Conclusion III follows because doctors overlap with teachers, and all teachers are engineers, ensuring some engineers are doctors.
- This option includes Conclusion II, which is invalid.
- A universal affirmative claim like All engineers are doctors cannot be deduced from partial overlapping statements.
Concept to know
- Syllogism problems can be solved using Venn diagrams or analytical rules of logic.
- Combining Statement 1 (Some doctors are teachers) and Statement 2 (All teachers are engineers) yields the valid deduction: Some doctors are engineers.
- Combining the result (Some doctors are engineers) with Statement 3 (All engineers are scientists) yields the valid deduction: Some doctors are scientists.
- Conversion Rule: A particular affirmative statement (Some A are B) converts validly to (Some B are A).
- Applying conversion to Some doctors are scientists gives Conclusion I (Some scientists are doctors), and converting Some doctors are engineers gives Conclusion III (Some engineers are doctors).
Related facts for revision
- Immediate inference rules such as conversion, obversion, and contraposition in categorical logic.
- Distribution of terms across categorical propositions (A, E, I, O types).
- Minimum overlapping Venn diagram approach to evaluate certainty versus possibility.
- Distinction between definite conclusions (must follow) and possible conclusions (may follow).
Ability to deduce valid logical conclusions from categorical propositions using syllogism rules or Venn diagrams.
Trap: Confusing partial overlap with universal inclusion, which tricks candidates into picking Conclusion II (All engineers are doctors).
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.