UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q40 · Reasoning
Eight students A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H sit around a circular table, equidistant from each other, facing the centre of the table, not necessarily in the same order. B and D sit neither adjacent to C nor opposite to C. A sits in between E and D, and F sits in between B and H. Which one of the following is definitely correct?
- aB sits in between A and G
- bC sits opposite to G
- cE sits opposite to F
- dNone of the above
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Multiple valid circular seating arrangements satisfy all given conditions, making none of the statements in options (a), (b), or (c) definitely true in all cases.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Consider the valid clockwise seating arrangement starting from position 1: C, G, D, A, E, B, F, H.
- In this arrangement, D sits between A and G, while B is at position 6.
- Since B does not sit between A and G in this valid configuration, option (a) is not definitely correct.
- In the valid arrangement C(1), G(2), D(3), A(4), E(5), B(6), F(7), H(8), position 5 opposite to C is occupied by E.
- G is located at position 2, which is adjacent to C, not opposite to C.
- Since G is not opposite to C in all valid seating configurations, option (b) is not definitely correct.
- In the valid arrangement C(1), E(2), A(3), D(4), G(5), B(6), F(7), H(8), E is at position 2 and its opposite position 6 is occupied by B.
- F is at position 7, which is opposite to position 3 occupied by A.
- Because E sits opposite to B rather than F in this valid layout, option (c) is not definitely correct.
- Because the given conditions allow for more than one distinct valid seating arrangement, statements (a), (b), and (c) are only possibilities, not absolute certainties.
- None of the specific seating claims are guaranteed to hold across all valid configurations.
- Therefore, option (d) is the correct answer.
Concept to know
- For 8 persons sitting around a circular table at equal distances facing the centre, opposite positions are exactly 4 places apart (Position N is opposite Position N+4).
- Statements like A sits in between E and D mean E, A, and D form a contiguous triplet block in either order E-A-D or D-A-E.
- Negative constraints, such as B and D not sitting adjacent to or opposite to C, eliminate specific positions relative to C.
- When evaluating a definitely correct conclusion in analytical reasoning, a statement must be true in every valid arrangement consistent with the rules.
- If even one valid arrangement invalidates a given option, that option cannot be considered definitely correct.
Related facts for revision
- Circular seating arrangements facing outward where direction conventions for left and right are reversed.
- Linear seating arrangement problems with directional facing constraints.
- Distinction between definitely true, possibly true, and definitely false conclusions in CSAT analytical puzzles.
- Complex matrix puzzles involving multi-variable grouping and scheduling constraints.
Ability to handle multi-scenario logical constraints and distinguish between a possible arrangement and a universally valid conclusion.
Trap: Candidates often stop after creating a single valid diagram where option (b) or (c) works, failing to test if alternative valid arrangements disprove them.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.