UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q12 · Comprehension
The poverty line is quite unsatisfactory when it comes to grasping the extent of poverty in India. It is not only because of its extremely narrow definition of 'who is poor' and the debatable methodology used to count the poor, but also because of a more fundamental assumption underlying it. It exclusively relies on the notion of poverty as insufficient income or insufficient purchasing power. One can better categorize it by calling it income poverty. If poverty is ultimately about deprivations affecting human well-being, then income poverty is only one aspect of it. Poverty of a life, in our view, lies not merely in the impoverished state in which the person actually lives, but also in the lack of real opportunity given by social constraints as well as personal circumstances—to choose other types of living. Even the relevance of low incomes, meagre possessions, and other aspects of what are standardly seen as economic poverty relate ultimately to their role in curtailing capabilities, i.e., their role in severely restricting the choices people have to lead variable and valued lives.
Why is the methodology adopted in India to count the 'poor' debatable?
- aThere is some confusion regarding what should constitute the 'poverty line'.
- bThere are wide diversities in the condition of the rural and urban poor.
- cThere is no uniform global standard for measuring income poverty.
- dIt is based on the proposition of poverty as meagre income or buying capacity.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly attributes the debate over the methodology to its exclusive reliance on defining poverty as insufficient income or purchasing power.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage does not mention any confusion regarding what elements should constitute the poverty line.
- It critiques the narrowness of the underlying assumption rather than any lack of clarity or ambiguity.
- Rural and urban differences in poverty conditions are not mentioned or discussed anywhere in the text.
- Selecting this option relies on external general knowledge rather than passage content.
- The passage makes no reference to global standards or international comparative frameworks.
- This option introduces outside information that is beyond the scope of the passage.
- The passage explicitly states that the methodology is unsatisfactory and debatable because it exclusively relies on the notion of poverty as insufficient income or purchasing power.
- Option (d) accurately paraphrases this key reason given in the second and third sentences of the text.
Concept to know
- Focus strictly on textual evidence provided within the passage without introducing real-world general knowledge.
- Identify explicit cause-and-effect relationships where the text explains why a particular methodology is criticized.
- Match options to paraphrased equivalents of the core statements in the passage.
- Eliminate options that introduce external facts such as rural-urban disparities or global standards when absent from the text.
Related facts for revision
- Direct reason questions where the answer must be supported by explicit statements in the context.
- Assumption questions requiring identification of underlying premises behind an author's argument.
- Main idea questions testing the ability to capture the core thesis without getting distracted by auxiliary points.
- Inference questions where correct choices logically follow from the passage facts without over-extrapolating.
Reading comprehension ability to identify explicit reasons given by the author for a specific critique.
Trap: Candidates often choose options like (b) or (c) because they represent true real-world facts, but CSAT passage questions must be solved strictly within the boundary of the provided text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.