UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q47 · Numeracy
A person X wants to distribute some pens among six children A, B, C, D, E and F. Suppose A gets twice the number of pens received by B, three times that of C, four times that of D, five times that of E and six times that of F. What is the minimum number of pens X should buy so that the number of pens each one gets is an even number?
- a147
- b150
- c294
- d300
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Setting A's share as a multiple of 60 ensures all shares are integers, and taking multiplier k = 2 ensures D's share (15k) is an even number, giving a minimum total of 294 pens.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- If total pens are 147, the multiplier k equals 1.
- For k = 1, D receives 15 × 1 = 15 pens, which is an odd number.
- This violates the question condition that every child must receive an even number of pens.
- 150 is not divisible by the total fraction sum ratio 147/60.
- It fails to give integer shares of pens for all six children.
- Therefore 150 cannot be the correct total number of pens.
- Taking multiplier k = 2 gives A = 120, B = 60, C = 40, D = 30, E = 24, and F = 20 pens.
- All individual shares are even numbers: 120, 60, 40, 30, 24, and 20.
- Total pens required = 120 + 60 + 40 + 30 + 24 + 20 = 294, which is the minimum possible total.
- 300 is not a multiple of 147 and does not satisfy the ratio requirement.
- Even though larger valid totals exist like 588 for k = 4, 300 is neither valid nor minimum.
Concept to know
- Ratio and Proportion formulation: Expressing all variable shares in terms of one main variable A, giving B = A/2, C = A/3, D = A/4, E = A/5, F = A/6.
- Least Common Multiple (LCM): Taking LCM of denominators 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 which is 60, so A must be a multiple of 60, i.e., A = 60k.
- Parity check constraint: Individual shares become A = 60k, B = 30k, C = 20k, D = 15k, E = 12k, F = 10k. For D = 15k to be even, k must be an even integer.
- Optimization: To minimize total pens 147k, choose the smallest positive even integer k = 2.
Related facts for revision
- LCM of denominators method for distributing discrete items into fractional ratios.
- Odd and even parity rules in basic algebraic expressions.
- Minimization problems under integer and parity constraints.
Ability to combine ratio simplification, LCM calculation, and parity (even/odd) constraints.
Trap: Choosing option (a) 147 by picking k = 1 without verifying if all individual shares (specifically D = 15) are even numbers.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.