UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q43 · Comprehension
The demographic dividend, which has begun in India and is expected to last another few decades, is a great window of opportunity. The demographic dividend is basically a swelling in the working age population, which conversely means that the relative ratio of very young and very old will, for a while, be on the decline. From the experience of Ireland and China, we know that this can be a source of energy and an engine of economic growth. The demographic dividend tends to raise a nation's savings rate since in any nation, it is the working age population that is the main saver. And since the savings rate is an important driver of growth, this should help elevate our growth rate. However, the benefits of demographic dividend depend on the quality of the working age population. And this implies bringing back the importance of education, acquisition of skills and human capital.
Which of the following would invariably happen in a country, when the demographic dividend has begun to operate?
1. The number of illiterate people will decrease.
2. The ratio of very old and very young will decrease for a while.
3. Population growth rate will quickly stabilize.
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
- a1 and 2 only
- b2 only
- c1 and 3 only
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement 2 is explicitly stated in the passage as the direct definitional consequence of a demographic dividend, whereas statements 1 and 3 are neither guaranteed nor mentioned as automatic occurrences.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage emphasizes education and skill acquisition as prerequisites to reap the benefits of demographic dividend, but it does not state that illiteracy will invariably decrease automatically upon its arrival.
- The passage explicitly states that demographic dividend means a swelling in the working age population, which conversely means that the relative ratio of very young and very old will, for a while, be on the decline.
- The passage makes no mention of the population growth rate stabilizing quickly as an inevitable result of the demographic dividend.
Concept to know
- Strict adherence to text boundaries is essential in CSAT reading comprehension questions.
- Directly stated facts in the passage take precedence over general real-world assumptions or economic theories.
- Extreme qualifiers like invariably or must happen require explicit direct support from the text.
- Prerequisites or policy recommendations mentioned in the text do not imply that those outcomes occur automatically.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying strong qualifiers such as invariably, completely, or always that invalidate unstated assumptions.
- Distinguishing between cause, correlation, and policy prerequisites in passage-based reasoning.
- Eliminating options that introduce unmentioned real-world facts or demographic concepts.
Ability to distinguish explicit text statements from plausible external assumptions and policy goals.
Trap: Candidates often choose Statement 1 because education is mentioned in the text, failing to note the strong word invariably which demands an automatic certainty not supported by the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.