UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q51 · Comprehension
In an economic organization, allowing mankind to benefit by the productivity of machines should lead to a very good life of leisure, and much leisure is apt to be tedious except to those who have intelligent activities and interests. If a leisured population is to be happy, it must be an educated population, and must be educated with a view to enjoyment as well as to the direct usefulness of technical knowledge.
Which of the following statements best reflects the underlying tone of the passage?
- aOnly an educated population can best make use of the benefits of economic progress.
- bAll economic development should be aimed at the creation of leisure.
- cAn increase in the educated population of a country leads to an increase in the happiness of its people.
- dUse of machines should be encouraged in order to create a large leisured population.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage establishes that machine productivity creates leisure, but leisure is tedious unless the population is educated to enjoy intelligent activities.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that economic organization and machine productivity provide leisure, but this leisure requires an educated population with intelligent interests to be enjoyable and avoid tediousness.
- This directly supports the conclusion that economic progress benefits society best when the population is educated enough to utilize the resulting leisure fruitfully.
- The author notes leisure as a byproduct of machine productivity, but nowhere suggests that all economic development must aim exclusively at creating leisure.
- This option makes an extreme normative claim using the word all which is not supported by the passage.
- The passage specifically discusses education in the context of enabling a leisured population to enjoy their time intelligently.
- It does not make a blanket assertion that increasing the educated population universally increases national happiness regardless of economic context.
- The passage treats machine productivity as a given feature of economic organization that yields leisure.
- It does not advocate for encouraging machine adoption for the purpose of generating a large leisured population; its concern is how people manage leisure once available.
Concept to know
- Main Idea and Underlying Tone Extraction: Identify the logical structure composed of the core premise, supporting evidence, and main conclusion.
- Premise: Machine productivity in economic organization generates increased leisure time.
- Constraint: Leisure without intelligent interests becomes tedious and unfulfilling.
- Solution and Conclusion: Education oriented toward intelligent enjoyment is necessary to truly realize the benefits of economic progress.
- Option Elimination Strategy: Eliminate options containing extreme claims, false causal links, or prescriptive actions not advocated by the author.
Related facts for revision
- CSAT Reading Comprehension: Identifying author purpose, tone, and central theme.
- Distinguishing necessary conditions from sufficient conditions in logical passages.
- Spotting extreme words like all, only, or must in comprehension options.
Ability to synthesize the core message of a passage without overgeneralizing or falling for overly broad options.
Trap: Candidates often choose Option (c) because education leading to happiness sounds intuitively correct, but it ignores the passage's specific focus on economic progress and leisure management.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.