UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q39 · Numeracy
A tram overtakes 2 persons X and Y walking at an average speed of 3 km/hr and 4 km/hr in the same direction and completely passes them in 8 seconds and 9 seconds respectively. What is the length of the tram ?
- a15 m
- b18 m
- c20 m
- d24 m
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Equating the tram length derived from relative speeds with both walking persons gives a tram speed of 12 km/hr and a length of 20 meters.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- 15 meters is incorrect.
- This result typically arises from calculation errors in relative speed equations or misapplying the unit conversion factor.
- 18 meters is incorrect.
- This value is obtained if one forgets to convert speeds from km/hr to m/s before multiplying by time in seconds.
- Let the speed of the tram be S km/hr.
- Equating length L = (S - 3) × (5/18) × 8 and L = (S - 4) × (5/18) × 9 gives (S - 3) × 8 = (S - 4) × 9, which solves to S = 12 km/hr.
- Substituting S = 12 back gives L = (12 - 3) × (5/18) × 8 = 9 × (5/18) × 8 = 20 meters.
- 24 meters is incorrect.
- This result occurs if speeds are added instead of subtracted, assuming opposite direction instead of same direction.
Concept to know
- Relative speed in same direction: When two objects move in the same direction, relative speed is the difference of their speeds (V1 - V2).
- Distance to pass a point object: When a train or tram completely passes a person, the distance covered relative to the person equals the length of the train.
- Speed conversion rule: To convert speed from km/hr to m/s, multiply by 5/18.
- Formulating linear equations: Express the total distance (tram length L) in terms of relative speed and time for both moving persons.
- Equating and solving: Since the tram length L is constant in both cases, set the two distance equations equal to solve for the tram speed and then find length L.
Related facts for revision
- Objects moving in opposite directions: Relative speed is the sum of speeds (V1 + V2), and distance covered is the sum of their lengths.
- Passing a stationary platform or bridge: Total distance covered by the train equals train length plus platform length.
- Passing a man inside another moving train: Relative speed is used, but distance covered is equal to the length of the passing train only.
- Speed and time inverse relationship: When distance is constant, relative speeds are inversely proportional to time taken.
Ability to handle relative speed problems, setup algebraic equations, and convert units between km/hr and m/s.
Trap: Forgetting to multiply by 5/18 when mixing km/hr and seconds, or adding speeds assuming opposite direction motion. Notice that (5/18) cancels out directly when equating the two distance expressions, saving calculation time.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.