UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q45 · Numeracy
A set (X) of 20 pipes can fill 70% of a tank in 14 minutes. Another set (Y) of 10 pipes fills 3/8th of the tank in 6 minutes. A third set (Z) of 16 pipes can empty half of the tank in 20 minutes. If half of the pipes of set X are closed and only half of the pipes of set Y are open, and all pipes of the set (Z) are open, then how long will it take to fill 50% of the tank?
- a8 minutes
- b10 minutes
- c12 minutes
- d16 minutes
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The net filling rate of 10 pipes of set X, 5 pipes of set Y, and 16 emptying pipes of set Z is 1/32 tank per minute, which fills 50% (1/2) of the tank in 16 minutes.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Calculating 8 minutes results from incorrectly doubling the net rate to 1/16 tank per minute.
- At the actual net rate of 1/32 tank per minute, 8 minutes will fill only 25% of the tank, not 50%.
- 10 minutes would fill 50% of the tank if the net rate were 1/20 tank per minute.
- At the net rate of 1/32 tank per minute, 10 minutes yields only 31.25% filled.
- 12 minutes corresponds to filling 37.5% of the tank at the net rate of 1/32 tank per minute.
- This option often arises if the emptying rate of set Z is incorrectly ignored or added.
- Rate of 10 pipes of set X (half of 20) is 0.70 / (14 * 2) = 1/40 tank per minute filling.
- Rate of 5 pipes of set Y (half of 10) is (3/8) / (6 * 2) = 1/32 tank per minute filling.
- Rate of 16 pipes of set Z (all) is (1/2) / 20 = 1/40 tank per minute emptying.
- Net filling rate = 1/40 + 1/32 - 1/40 = 1/32 tank per minute.
- Time needed for 50% (1/2) tank = (1/2) / (1/32) = 16 minutes.
Concept to know
- Work Rate Formula: Work Rate = Portion of Work / Time Taken.
- Unitary Method for Multiple Workers: Total rate of a group of identical pipes is directly proportional to the number of active pipes.
- Inlet vs Outlet Pipes: Inlet pipes contribute positive work rate (filling) while outlet pipes contribute negative work rate (emptying).
- Net Combined Rate: Combined Rate = Sum of rates of active inlet pipes minus sum of rates of active outlet pipes.
- Time to Complete Target Work: Required Time = Target Work Portion / Net Combined Rate.
Related facts for revision
- Pipes and Cistern problems with alternating operation of inlets and outlets.
- Problems involving variable pipe efficiencies or non-identical filling rates.
- Time and Work problems involving positive work (building a structure) and negative work (dismantling a structure).
- Capacity-based assumptions using LCM of given time values as a shortcut.
Mathematical aptitude in combined positive and negative work rates under fractional efficiency conditions.
Trap: Forgetting that outlet pipes do negative work by adding instead of subtracting set Z's rate, or miscalculating the target work as 100% instead of 50%.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.