UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q33 · Comprehension
If there is inequality in the pattern of population growth, there is greater inequality in food production and utilization. As societies become wealthier, their consumption of animal products increases. This means that a greater proportion of such basic foodstuff as grains and legumes that could feed humans directly is instead being converted into feed for poultry and large farm animals. Yet this conversion of plant-based food into animal food for humans is far from efficient. Only 16% of the calories fed to chickens are recovered by us when we eat them. This conversion rate goes down to five to seven per cent in large animals that are fed grain to add fat and some protein before slaughter.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crux of the passage ?
- aThere is an urgent need for a public policy to promote the consumption of cereal-based foods in wealthier societies.
- bAnimal-based food is far less efficient than grain/plant-based food in terms of production and utilization.
- cPlant-based protein should replace the animal-based protein in our daily diets.
- dInequality in food production and consumption is inevitable in any fast changing society.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly demonstrates that converting plant food into animal food yields very low calorie efficiency, showing animal-based food is far less efficient than plant-based food in production and utilization.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage notes that wealthier societies consume more animal products, but it nowhere prescribes or advocates for an urgent public policy.
- Recommending a specific public policy intervention goes beyond the factual statements provided in the text.
- The author explicitly states that the conversion of plant-based food into animal food for humans is far from efficient.
- Numerical data showing low calorie recovery of 16% in chickens and 5 to 7 per cent in large animals directly supports the lower efficiency of animal-based food.
- The passage discusses low conversion efficiency of plant feed into animal calories.
- It does not make a normative recommendation or moral judgment that plant protein should replace animal protein in daily diets.
- The passage mentions inequality in food production and utilization at the beginning.
- It does not claim or imply that such inequality is inevitable in any fast changing society.
Concept to know
- Crux or central idea questions require identifying the core thesis supported by all major premise sentences in the text.
- Avoid policy recommendations or normative solutions unless they are explicitly stated by the author in the passage.
- Distinguish between supporting evidence such as statistics and the primary conclusion drawn from that evidence.
- Extreme or absolute terms like inevitable across all fast changing societies usually indicate incorrect options.
- A correct crux statement distills the main factual argument without introducing unstated external assumptions.
Related facts for revision
- Main idea questions requiring synthesis of premise and evidence
- Inference questions testing logical bounds of the given passage
- Assumption questions identifying unstated premises
- Author intent questions distinguishing descriptive statements from normative claims
Ability to extract the central argument of a passage without being misled by plausible real-world recommendations.
Trap: Options (a) and (c) sound like sensible real-world policy solutions, tempting candidates to pick normative advice that the passage itself does not contain.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.