UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q11 · Comprehension
Each State in India faces a distinctive set of challenges regarding the impact of warming, but also offers its own set of opportunities for reducing emissions depending on its natural resources. For example, coastal States need to take action to protect their shores from sea level rise, districts that are drier need to prepare for variable monsoon precipitation. Himalayan regions have their own unique challenges, and selected parts of peninsular India and offshore areas offer great opportunities for harnessing wind power. These various aspects need to be considered for developing clear and sustainable goals for the future.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical, rational and pragmatic message conveyed by the author of the passage ?
- aThe mitigation and adaptation strategies to address/tackle the climate change is essentially the responsibility of each State.
- bIndia is too diverse to implement any effective strategy or programme to address/tackle the climate change.
- cIt is basically the responsibility of the Union Government to implement the climate action plans and ensure net zero emissions.
- dIndia needs to formulate effective climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies at the State/region level.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly emphasizes that climate challenges and opportunities vary by geography and natural resources, necessitating localized strategies at the State and regional levels.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage highlights the need for localized strategies based on regional diversity.
- It does not declare climate action to be essentially or solely the responsibility of individual States to the exclusion of central policy.
- The word essentially shifts the focus from decentralized strategy formulation to fixed legal responsibility.
- This option presents an overly pessimistic view that diversity prevents effective action.
- The passage takes a constructive tone, arguing that regional diversity provides specific opportunities for harnessing resources like wind power.
- Contradicts the concluding recommendation of the passage to develop clear and sustainable goals.
- The passage focuses on regional and state-specific variations and tailored action plans.
- It directly contradicts the idea that climate action is basically the sole responsibility of the Union Government.
- Over-centralizes an issue that the author explicitly describes as context-dependent across states.
- The passage details how different regions like coastal, dry districts, Himalayan, and peninsular areas have unique needs and opportunities.
- It concludes that these various aspects need to be considered for developing future goals.
- This directly supports the conclusion that climate strategies must be formulated at the State/region level.
Concept to know
- Identify the main logical message by synthesizing specific regional examples into a broader policy principle.
- Avoid options containing extreme or rigid language such as essentially the responsibility or too diverse to implement.
- Distinguish between a constructive policy recommendation and a defeatist or overly narrow assignment of legal duty.
- Match the scope of the main idea with the textual evidence provided in the passage.
- Evaluate reading comprehension options strictly based on the text without adding external legal or administrative assumptions.
Related facts for revision
- Author's Message and Main Idea question patterns in CSAT Reading Comprehension.
- Elimination techniques targeting extreme qualifiers in reading passages.
- Inference questions centered on environmental policy and decentralized governance themes.
Ability to synthesize specific contextual examples into a pragmatic and logical overall policy message.
Trap: Option (a) tricks test-takers because it mentions State-level action, but introduces an unjustified absolute claim about responsibility.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.