UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q41 · Comprehension
Over the next 30 years, many countries are promising to move to net-zero carbon, implying that household emissions will have to be cut to close to nothing. A leading climate scientist reckons that, at best, half the reduction might be achieved through demand-side measures, such as behavioural changes by individuals and households. And even that would require companies and governments to provide more incentives to change through supply-side investments to make low-carbon options cheaper and more widely available.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the central idea conveyed by the passage?
- aMoving to net-zero carbon is possible only by the reduction in household emissions.
- bLow-carbon behaviour in people can be brought about by incentivising them.
- cCheaper goods and services can be made available to people by using low-carbon technologies.
- dManufacturing industries that use low-carbon technologies should be provided with subsidies.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly highlights that behavioural changes in households require incentives provided by governments and companies through supply-side investments.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The word only makes it an extreme statement not supported by the passage.
- The passage notes that demand-side measures can at best achieve half the required reduction, implying supply-side action is also necessary.
- The passage directly connects behavioural changes in households to incentives provided by companies and governments.
- It states that supply-side investments are required to make low-carbon options cheaper and more widely available to encourage individual action.
- This distorts the cause-and-effect relationship given in the text.
- The passage states that supply-side investments are needed to make low-carbon options cheaper, not that using low-carbon tech inherently lowers general prices of goods and services.
- The passage does not mention manufacturing industries or subsidies specifically.
- Introducing concepts like subsidies for manufacturing industries brings in outside information not contained within the text.
Concept to know
- Identify the core argument by looking for conditional statements that connect an action with its necessary enabling condition.
- Eliminate extreme qualifiers such as only, completely, or solely unless explicitly supported by the text.
- Filter out out-of-scope terms like subsidies or manufacturing industries that do not appear in the reading passage.
- Trace logical cause and effect strictly as stated in the text without reversing or over-generalizing them.
- Synthesize demand-side and supply-side links to capture the central thesis of the author.
Related facts for revision
- Central idea versus supporting detail question types in reading comprehension.
- Extreme modifier traps commonly tested in CSAT reading comprehension passages.
- Differentiating between broad incentives and specific economic instruments like subsidies.
- Identifying out-of-scope distractors in CSAT verbal ability questions.
Ability to extract the primary thesis of a passage while filtering out extreme options and out-of-scope assumptions.
Trap: Candidates often choose option (a) due to the focus on household emissions, ignoring the word 'only', or option (d) by introducing external knowledge about subsidies.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.