EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q71 · Comprehension

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ71
SubjectComprehension

A single number for inflation is an aggregate across different commodities and services - the price rise differs for different items of consumption. So, the single number is arrived at by assigning weights to different commodities and services. For WPI, the weights in production are used; for CPI, the consumption basket is used. But people are not homogeneous. The consumption basket is vastly different for the poor, the middle classes, and the rich. Hence, the CPI is different for each of these classes and a composite index requires averaging the baskets.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical, rational and crucial message conveyed by the passage ?

  1. aWe must use WPI exclusively in measuring price rise and CPI should be done away with.
  2. bThe present calculation of inflation rate does not correctly measure price rise of individual item/commodity.
  3. cInflation data under-presents services in the consumption basket.
  4. dKnowledge of inflation rate is not really of any use to anybody in the country.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) The present calculation of inflation rate does not correctly measure price rise of individual item/commodity.

The passage explains that inflation is an aggregate figure averaged across diverse commodities and non-homogeneous social classes, meaning the single composite index fails to accurately reflect the specific price rise of individual items.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • The passage describes how WPI and CPI assign weights but nowhere recommends discarding CPI or using WPI exclusively.
  • Making an extreme policy recommendation to abolish CPI is entirely unsupported by the passage.
✓ Option (b)
  • The passage explicitly notes that price rise differs across items and that inflation is calculated as a single weighted aggregate or average.
  • Because composite averaging pools vastly different items and social baskets together, the resulting single inflation rate does not accurately capture the specific price rise of an individual item or commodity.
✗ Option (c)
  • The passage mentions goods and services generally, but it makes no claim regarding the under-representation of services in the consumption basket.
  • Bringing in claims about service coverage relies on external economic knowledge rather than the text itself.
✗ Option (d)
  • The passage highlights the statistical limitations of averaging in a single inflation index, but it does not claim that inflation data is completely useless.
  • Option (d) expresses an extreme and unfounded conclusion that contradicts the analytical nature of the passage.

Concept to know

  • Primary Message Identification: CSAT Reading Comprehension requires identifying the core analytical point of the passage rather than drawing unstated policy conclusions.
  • Scope Bound Rule: The correct option must strictly reflect the logical framework of the text without importing external knowledge or personal opinions.
  • Elimination of Extreme Phrasing: Words like exclusively, done away with, or not of any use signal extreme statements that are rarely correct in CSAT inference questions.
  • Understanding Aggregation Limitations: When a passage explains how varied data points are averaged into a single index, the central message usually highlights the loss of individual granular detail.
  • Distinction Between Limitation and Uselessness: Pointing out the measurement limitations of a statistic does not mean the author considers the statistic useless or advocates its complete removal.

Related facts for revision

  • Main Idea versus Assumption Questions: Main idea questions seek the explicit or closely derived conclusion, whereas assumption questions seek unstated necessary premises.
  • External Knowledge Trap: Passage-based questions in economics frequently tempt candidates into picking options based on pre-existing knowledge about WPI or CPI rather than the text.
  • Tone Analysis Technique: Analytical passages call for balanced and measured options; radical or absolute claims should be eliminated.
  • Distractor Pattern Recognition: Options that take a valid observation and stretch it into an extreme generalization are standard CSAT distractors.
How UPSC tests this

Evaluating critical reading skills and the ability to extract the main analytical limitation of an aggregated economic index without overreaching.

Trap: Selecting extreme options like (a) or (d) due to sweeping language, or selecting (c) based on background knowledge about service weights in inflation indices.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.