EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q49 · Reasoning

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ49
SubjectReasoning

A mobile phone has been stolen. There are 3 suspects P, Q and R. They were questioned knowing that only one of them is guilty. Their responses are as follows :
P : I did not steal. Q stole it.
Q : R did not steal. I did not steal.
R : I did not steal. I do not know who did it.
Who stole the mobile phone?

  1. aP
  2. bQ
  3. cR
  4. dCannot be concluded
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Cannot be concluded

Without specified conditions on who is telling the truth or lying, any suspect could logically be guilty, making a unique conclusion impossible.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • If P is the thief, P lies in both statements while Q and R state true statements.
  • Because no rule forces the thief to lie or innocent people to tell the truth, P being guilty is possible but cannot be uniquely proved.
✗ Option (b)
  • If Q is the thief, P statement that Q stole it becomes true, and Q statement about self becomes false.
  • Without truth-telling constraints provided in the question, Q being guilty is also a possible scenario but not unique.
✗ Option (c)
  • If R is the thief, R statement about not stealing is false and statements by P and Q contain false elements.
  • This scenario is equally consistent under loose assumptions, so R cannot be definitively chosen.
✓ Option (d)
  • The question states only one person is guilty, but provides no rule regarding who speaks truth or who lies.
  • Assuming different truth-values for each statement allows every suspect to be consistent with the premise.
  • Therefore, it is logically impossible to conclude uniquely who stole the mobile phone.

Concept to know

  • Logic Puzzles with Truth Values: standard truth-teller and liar puzzles require explicit rules, such as all innocent suspects tell the truth and the guilty suspect lies.
  • Evaluating Missing Constraints: when constraints on truthfulness are absent, any suspect can be consistent by arbitrarily assigning truth or falsehood to their statements.
  • Case-by-Case Hypothesis Testing: test each suspect as the guilty party and evaluate if any logical contradiction arises under the given constraints.
  • Logical Completeness Requirement: a unique conclusion requires that exactly one hypothesis is logically consistent while all others produce explicit contradictions.

Related facts for revision

  • Knights and Knaves Puzzles: classic logic problems where one group always speaks the truth and another always lies.
  • Single Truth-Teller Variations: questions where exactly one person tells the truth or exactly one person lies among all given statements.
  • Elimination Technique: systematically assuming each suspect is guilty to check which assumption leads to a clear logical contradiction.
  • Data Sufficiency in Logic: recognizing when a problem lacks necessary rules to yield a single deterministic answer.
How UPSC tests this

Logical reasoning and the ability to evaluate whether given premises contain sufficient constraints to derive a unique conclusion.

Trap: Assuming unstated rules like the thief always lies and innocent suspects always tell the truth, which tempts candidates into selecting option Q or P.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.