EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q24 · Comprehension

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ24
SubjectComprehension

In our country, handlooms are equated with a culture that ensures a continuity of tradition. This idea has become part of the public policy-framing and provides a legitimate basis for the State to support the sector. But the notion of tradition as a single, linear entity is being strongly contested today. The narratives dominant in defining culture/tradition in a particular way are seen to have emerged as the identities and histories of large sections. The discounted and, at times, forcibly stifled identities are fighting for their rightful place in history. Against this backdrop, when we promote handloom as a traditional industry, it is not surprising that large sections of our population choose to ignore it.

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
I. There is no need for the State to be involved in any manner in the handloom sector.
II. Handloom products are no longer appealing and attractive in the rapidly changing modern world.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid ?

  1. aI only
  2. bII only
  3. cBoth I and II
  4. dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Neither I nor II

Neither assumption is valid because the author critiques the narrow cultural rationale for State support rather than advocating total non-involvement, and explains public neglect through identity politics rather than product appeal.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement I
  • The passage questions the specific rationale used by the State to support the sector (a single, linear notion of tradition), but it does not claim or assume that the State should withdraw entirely.
  • The phrase in any manner makes Statement I an extreme claim that goes far beyond the author critique of public policy framing.
✗ Statement II
  • The passage attributes the ignoring of handloom to identity conflict and dominant exclusionary narratives of tradition, not to product aesthetics or modernization.
  • Introducing the idea of a rapidly changing modern world brings in an unstated external factor that is neither mentioned nor implied by the author.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must believe to be true for the argument to hold logic.
  • Extreme qualifiers such as in any manner or completely usually invalidate an assumption unless explicitly necessitated by the text.
  • Under the Negation Test, if negating a statement does not destroy the central argument, that statement is not a valid assumption.
  • Distinguish between internal causes stated in the passage (exclusionary cultural narrative) and external plausible causes (modern fashion trends).
  • Keep the analysis strictly restricted to the text without importing real-world economic facts about handlooms or subsidies.

Related facts for revision

  • Assumption questions versus Inference questions: inferences are logical conclusions derived from facts, whereas assumptions are hidden prerequisites.
  • Negation Technique: Negating Statement I to State involvement might be needed under a redefined inclusive framework leaves the author argument intact.
  • CSAT distractor patterns frequently use total policy abolition options to trap candidates who mistake critique for total rejection.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to identify implicit assumptions without falling for extreme policy generalizations or plausible external reasons.

Trap: Candidates often choose option (b) or (c) assuming that ignoring handlooms implies the products are out of fashion, confusing real-world general logic with the passage specific identity-based reasoning.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.