UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q51 · Comprehension
It is hard to predict how changes in the climate and the atmosphere's chemistry will affect the prevalence and virulence of agricultural diseases. But there is a risk that such changes will make some plant infections more common in all climatic zones, perhaps catastrophically so. Part of the problem is that centuries of selective breeding have refined the genomes of most high-value crops. They are spectacular at growing in today's conditions but genetic variations that are not immediately useful to them have been bred out. This is good for yields but bad for coping with changes. A minor disease or even an unknown one could suddenly rampage through a genetically honed crop.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the central idea conveyed by the passage ?
- aGlobal climate change adversely affects the productivity of crops.
- bOur total dependence on genetically honed crops entails possible food insecurity.
- cOur food security should not depend on agricultural productivity alone.
- dGenetically honed crops should be replaced with their wild varieties in our present cultivation practices.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that relying exclusively on genetically honed crops lacking genetic variation makes agriculture highly vulnerable to climate-induced disease outbreaks, threatening food security.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage mentions climate change affecting disease prevalence, but its central focus is on genetic homogeneity as the core vulnerability rather than climate change alone.
- It captures only a supporting premise rather than the main takeaway or core argument of the author.
- The passage explicitly states that centuries of selective breeding have removed genetic variations needed by crops to cope with novel diseases.
- Relying entirely on such vulnerable, genetically honed crops creates a risk of sudden widespread crop destruction, directly implying food insecurity.
- The text does not discuss non-productivity aspects of food security such as supply chains, equitable distribution, or food access.
- This option introduces external general knowledge concepts not supported or implied by the text.
- The passage highlights the risks of genetic uniformity, but it never advocates replacing high-yielding crops entirely with wild varieties.
- Recommending an extreme actionable remedy goes beyond the scope and narrative of the passage.
Concept to know
- Identify the central thesis by distinguishing between the primary argument and secondary background context.
- Trace the logical chain of causality: selective breeding reduces genetic diversity, which increases crop vulnerability under climate change, leading to food security threats.
- Recognize the scope of the passage and reject options that introduce outside concepts such as food distribution or policy solutions.
- Beware of extreme prescriptive traps where an option proposes radical remedies not suggested by the author.
- Synthesize cause and ultimate consequence to select the option that best encapsulates the whole passage.
Related facts for revision
- Central Idea versus Supporting Detail questions where options state true facts from the text that are not the main point.
- Prescriptive Remedy traps where candidates confuse an analytical observation with an extreme policy recommendation.
- Inference questions on monoculture, genetic erosion, and agricultural climate resilience.
Ability to filter out context premises and isolate the primary central message of a passage.
Trap: Option (d) traps students by offering a plausible real-world solution, but UPSC reading comprehension strict rules forbid choosing extreme recommendations not mentioned in the text.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.