UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q9 · Numeracy
Team X scored a total of N runs in 20 overs. Team Y tied the score in 10% less overs. Had team Y's average run rate (runs per over) been 50% higher, the scores would have been tied in 12 overs. How many runs were scored by team X ?
- a72
- b144
- c216
- dCannot be determined
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The given conditions reduce to an algebraic identity where the total runs N cancel out completely, leaving N undetermined.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- 72 is a possible value for N, but it is not unique because any positive value of N satisfies the given conditions.
- 144 is a possible value for N, but it is not unique because the second condition reduces to the identity N = N.
- 216 is a possible value for N, but it cannot be uniquely determined because the problem lacks an independent equation.
- Team Y takes 20 × (1 - 0.10) = 18 overs to score N runs, giving an original run rate of N / 18 runs per over.
- A 50% increase in run rate gives a new rate of 1.5 × (N / 18) = N / 12 runs per over.
- The overs needed at this new rate to score N runs is N / (N / 12) = 12 overs, which is a mathematical identity true for all positive values of N, making N indeterminable.
Concept to know
- Run rate is defined as total runs scored divided by total overs taken.
- For a fixed target score N, run rate and overs taken are inversely proportional quantities.
- A unique value for a variable can only be found if there are sufficient independent equations.
- When a word problem statement simplifies to a standard mathematical identity like N = N, it provides no new quantitative constraint.
- To evaluate Cannot be determined in CSAT questions, check whether variables cancel out completely during simplification.
Related facts for revision
- Time and Work problems where total work cancels out while comparing rates.
- Speed, Distance, and Time problems where distance cancels out completely.
- Data Sufficiency questions involving redundant or linearly dependent statements.
- Percentage change relationships between inversely proportional variables.
Testing the candidate ability to recognize linearly dependent algebraic statements and avoid assuming arbitrary values when variables cancel out.
Trap: Candidates often assume N must be a common multiple of 20, 18, and 12 such as 72, 144, or 216 and pick a specific numeric option instead of verifying if N is uniquely solvable.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.