EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q44 · Comprehension

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ44
SubjectComprehension

In only 50 years, the world's consumption of raw materials has nearly quadrupled, to more than 100 billion tons. Less than 9% of this is reused. Batteries of old vehicles contain materials such as lithium, cobalt, manganese and nickel that are pricey and can be hard to obtain. Supply chains are long and complicated. Buyers' risks are being aggravated by their suppliers' poor environmental and labour standards. Reusing materials makes sense. Once batteries reach the ends of their lives, they should go back to a factory where their ingredients can be recovered and put into new batteries.

With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
I. Automobile factories are examples of the circular economy.
II. Economic growth is compatible with circular use of mineral resources.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?

  1. aI only
  2. bII only
  3. cBoth I and II
  4. dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(b) II only

Statement I assumes current automobile factories already exemplify a circular economy whereas the passage only suggests what should happen, while Statement II correctly identifies the unstated premise that economic growth can coexist with resource recycling.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement I
  • The passage explicitly states that less than 9 percent of raw materials are currently reused and suggests that end of life batteries should go back to a factory.
  • It presents component recycling as a recommended future practice rather than asserting that present automobile factories are already functioning circular economy models.
  • Confusing a normative recommendation with a current descriptive fact makes Statement I an invalid assumption.
✓ Statement II
  • The passage connects quadrupled material consumption and demand for new batteries with the recommendation to recover ingredients from old batteries.
  • The underlying argument that manufacturing can continue through recycled minerals relies on the premise that economic activity is compatible with circular resource use.
  • Negating Statement II would mean economic growth cannot be sustained alongside circular resource use, which would invalidate the author's proposed solution.

Concept to know

  • An assumption is an unstated implicit premise that must hold true for the argument's conclusion to remain logically valid.
  • Distinguish between descriptive statements that report present facts and normative statements that suggest what ought to be done.
  • Avoid overgeneralization traps where a proposed ideal practice is mistakenly assumed to be an existing industry-wide standard.
  • Apply the negation test to evaluate assumptions by checking if reversing the premise causes the central logic of the passage to collapse.
  • Maintain absolute fidelity to the passage boundary without introducing external domain knowledge about modern manufacturing.

Related facts for revision

  • Implicit assumption questions requiring the bridging gap between context premises and final conclusions.
  • Inference questions demanding direct logical deductions rather than unstated foundational assumptions.
  • Strengthening and weakening argument questions evaluating how new information impacts underlying premises.
  • Passages dealing with economic and environmental trade-offs requiring identification of core sustainability logic.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to identify valid unstated assumptions and distinguish normative recommendations from present descriptive facts.

Trap: Choosing option (c) by assuming Statement I is true based on real-world knowledge of existing EV battery recycling programs rather than relying strictly on the text.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.