UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q19 · Reasoning
Consider the following statements :
I. If A ≤ B > C < D > E > F ≥ G = H; then B is always greater than E.
II. If P > Q = R ≥ S = T ≤ U = V > W; then S is always less than V.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Both statements are false because Statement I contains opposing inequality signs between B and E preventing any relationship, and Statement II yields S ≤ V which permits S = V rather than strictly S < V.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Evaluating Statement I: A ≤ B > C < D > E > F ≥ G = H.
- The path connecting B to E is B > C < D > E.
- Because both greater-than (>) and less-than (<) signs appear between B and E, no definite relationship exists between them, making Statement I false.
- Evaluating Statement II: P > Q = R ≥ S = T ≤ U = V > W.
- The path connecting S to V is S = T ≤ U = V, which simplifies directly to S ≤ V.
- This means S can be less than V or equal to V, so S is not always strictly less than V, making Statement II false.
- Statement I is false because opposing signs prevent a conclusion.
- Statement II is false because S can also equal V.
- Since both statements are false, Option (c) is incorrect.
- Statement I fails due to conflicting inequality directions between B and E.
- Statement II fails because S ≤ V permits S = V, so S < V is not always true.
- Therefore, neither Statement I nor Statement II is correct.
Concept to know
- In inequality chains, a definite relationship between two elements can only be established if all inequality symbols along the path face the same direction.
- When opposing symbols such as greater-than (>) and less-than (<) appear together in the path between two variables, no comparison can be determined.
- The symbol ≤ represents less than or equal to, meaning equality is a valid outcome alongside strict inequality.
- Priority order of inequality operators is Strict Inequality (> or <) over Semi-Strict Inequality (≥ or ≤) over Equality (=).
- Statements containing absolute words like always require the relationship to hold true in 100 percent of possible cases including boundary equal cases.
Related facts for revision
- Coded inequalities using symbols like @, #, $, %, & to substitute for mathematical comparison operators.
- Either-or conclusions in inequalities where combined cases cover all possibilities such as S < V or S = V when S ≤ V is established.
- Merging two or more separate inequality statements using common terms to form a single continuous chain.
Testing the ability to evaluate mathematical inequality chains and distinguish between strict inequality and semi-strict inequality.
Trap: Candidates often confuse S ≤ V with strictly S < V, forgetting that the possibility of equality S = V invalidates the word always.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.