UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q23 · Comprehension
In our country, handlooms are equated with a culture that ensures a continuity of tradition. This idea has become part of the public policy-framing and provides a legitimate basis for the State to support the sector. But the notion of tradition as a single, linear entity is being strongly contested today. The narratives dominant in defining culture/tradition in a particular way are seen to have emerged as the identities and histories of large sections. The discounted and, at times, forcibly stifled identities are fighting for their rightful place in history. Against this backdrop, when we promote handloom as a traditional industry, it is not surprising that large sections of our population choose to ignore it.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and rational message conveyed by the author of the passage ?
- aWe need to free the handloom industry from the limited narrative linked to preserving cultural heritage.
- bContinued State support to the handloom industry ensures the preservation of some of our glorious art forms and old traditions.
- cHousehold units of the handloom sector should be modernized and made an economically viable organized industry.
- dHandloom products need to be converted to machine-made designer products so as to make them more popular.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that tying handloom solely to a linear narrative of cultural tradition alienates large sections of the population, implying the need to decouple handloom from this narrow narrative.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The author argues that equating handlooms with a single linear narrative of tradition causes large sections of the population to ignore handloom products.
- Therefore, liberating the handloom sector from this limited narrative is the most logical step to widen its acceptance and relevance.
- This statement reiterates the traditional State justification which the author explicitly criticizes.
- The passage states that the notion of tradition as a linear entity is contested and leads to the exclusion of stifled identities.
- The passage does not discuss modernizing household units or transforming handlooms into an organized industry.
- Introducing external ideas about economic viability goes beyond the facts and scope presented in the text.
- The text makes no mention of converting handloom items into machine-made designer goods.
- Converting handloom products into machine-made goods is logically contradictory to the fundamental concept of handlooms.
Concept to know
- Identifying the author main message requires synthesizing the premise problem and implied solution presented in the passage.
- Distinguish between the State official stance described in the text and the author critical evaluation of that stance.
- Avoid external assumptions or solutions such as modernization or mechanization that are not supported by the passage text.
- Trace logical causality where narrow traditional framing leads to public neglect, implying the need for narrative reform.
Related facts for revision
- Main idea and central theme identification questions in CSAT Reading Comprehension.
- Logical corollary and inference questions where solutions must directly address the core problem defined by the author.
- Tone analysis questions involving critical, analytical, or evaluative passages regarding public policy.
Ability to identify the core message and logical implication of a critical narrative without adding external assumptions.
Trap: Option (b) is a trap because it repeats the prevailing public policy rationale mentioned in the passage, but misses the author's critique of it.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.