EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q22 · Comprehension

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ22
SubjectComprehension

One of the dismal realities of the agricultural sector in independent India has been that it never experienced a high-growth phase, unlike the non-agricultural economy. The highest decadal growth (compound annual growth rate or CAGR) for agriculture has been just 3.5% in the 1980s. Also, after experiencing a spurt in decadal growth during the 1980s, agricultural growth suffered relative stagnation thereafter. This is in sharp contrast to non-agricultural growth, which consistently increased from the 1980s to 2000s.

With reference to the passage, the following assumptions have been made :
I. adapting large-scale cultivation of commercial crops and viable corporate farming.
II. providing free insurance for all crops and heavily subsidizing seeds, fertilizers, electricity and farm machinery at par with developed countries.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid ?

  1. aI only
  2. bII only
  3. cBoth I and II
  4. dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Neither I nor II

Neither statement is an unstated premise or necessary assumption of the passage, which merely provides historical data contrasting agricultural and non-agricultural growth rates.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Statement I
  • The passage only presents historical statistical facts regarding decadal growth rates in agriculture versus non-agricultural sectors.
  • It does not discuss policy solutions, commercial crop cultivation, or corporate farming.
  • An assumption must be a premise required for the passage logic to hold, which is not present here.
✗ Statement II
  • The text contains no reference to crop insurance, seed subsidies, fertilizer policies, or comparison with developed countries.
  • Extrapolating policy prescriptions regarding free insurance and heavy subsidies introduces outside general knowledge not grounded in the passage.
  • Therefore, Statement II cannot be logically validated as an assumption underlying the given text.

Concept to know

  • Definition of an Assumption: An assumption is an unstated belief or premise that the author must hold to be true for the main factual argument of the passage to hold logical ground.
  • Boundary Rule: Assumptions must be strictly bounded by the scope and logic of the provided text, without introducing extraneous outside general knowledge or policy solutions.
  • Fact versus Recommendation Distinction: Descriptive passages that present historical data or facts rarely contain implicit policy assumptions unless the author draws an explicit normative conclusion.
  • The Negation Test: To verify an assumption, negate the statement; if the author's core argument collapses, the assumption is valid; if the core argument remains unaffected, it is invalid.
  • Avoiding Real-World Knowledge Traps: UPSC CSAT RC questions evaluate logical inference from given text, not the general validity of economic policy options in real life.

Related facts for revision

  • Assumption versus Inference: An inference is a conclusion derived directly from facts, whereas an assumption is an unstated premise required to reach the conclusion.
  • Crucial Message or Main Idea Questions: Focus on identifying the central takeaway or thesis rather than underlying unstated premises.
  • Extraneous General Knowledge Trap: Questions where options state valid real-world policies that are nowhere supported by the passage text.
  • Descriptive versus Normative Passages: Identifying whether a passage describes historical facts or advocates specific policy actions helps eliminate invalid assumptions.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to distinguish implicit assumptions required by a text from external real-world policy suggestions not supported by the passage.

Trap: Candidates often pick option (c) or options with I/II because corporate farming and subsidies sound like real-world solutions for agricultural stagnation, forgetting that CSAT Reading Comprehension relies strictly on passage evidence.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.