UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q1 · Comprehension
Maintaining an ecosystem just to conserve biodiversity will affect its commercial potential as well as the livelihoods dependent on the ecosystem. There is also a conflict between using an ecosystem only for livelihoods, for commercial exploitation, or strictly for conservation. Deforestation caused due to commercial exploitation will lead to indirect harm like floods, siltation problems and microclimatic instability, apart from adversely affecting livelihoods dependent on forests. These conflicts are particularly acute in developing countries where the dependence of people on the ecosystem is significant, and commercial exploitation has the potential to boost national income.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the critical message conveyed by the author of the passage ?
- aConservation of biodiversity is not an issue to be worried about when some people depend on ecosystems for their livelihoods.
- bCommercial exploitation of forests goes against the fundamental rights of the people dependent on forests for food and shelter.
- cSustenance of livelihood and degradation of ecosystem while being together exacerbate one another, leading to conflicts and imbalance.
- dCommercial exploitation of ecosystems should be completely stopped.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
It accurately captures the central thesis of the passage regarding the mutual exacerbation of ecological degradation and livelihood sustenance leading to systemic conflicts.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The author emphasizes the existence of a multi-dimensional conflict, not that biodiversity conservation should be ignored when livelihoods are involved.
- Dismissing conservation contradicts the passage's explicit concern over environmental degradation like floods and microclimatic instability.
- The passage mentions impacts on forest-dependent livelihoods but does not state or imply that commercial exploitation violates legal or fundamental rights.
- Introducing constitutional terms like fundamental rights makes this choice an out-of-scope assertion.
- The passage details how commercial exploitation causes ecosystem degradation such as deforestation, floods, and siltation, which in turn harms forest-dependent livelihoods.
- It explicitly highlights the acute conflict and imbalance arising when livelihood reliance, commercial exploitation, and conservation pressures exist together.
- The passage does not advocate for an absolute ban on commercial exploitation, noting that commercial activities have the potential to boost national income in developing countries.
- Suggesting a complete stop is an extreme normative stance unsupported by the analytical tone of the passage.
Concept to know
- Critical Message Identification Strategy: Focus on the central thesis of the passage rather than narrow facts or extreme statements.
- Distinguishing Implicit Premises from Extreme Inferences: Avoid options that prescribe absolute policies like completely stopping an activity unless explicitly argued by the author.
- Eliminating Out-of-Scope Concepts: Reject options introducing external terms such as fundamental rights that are not discussed or implied in the text.
- Synthesizing Multi-Pronged Conflicts: Recognize how the author connects cause-and-effect loops between economic drivers, environmental degradation, and human welfare.
Related facts for revision
- Author Tone Analysis: Identifying whether an author is analytical, prescriptive, critical, or neutral to rule out overly aggressive recommendations.
- Assumption vs Inference vs Main Message Questions: Understanding that main message questions require capturing the core takeaway without overstepping text boundaries.
- Common CSAT Trap Patterns: Spotting extreme keywords such as completely, never, always, or rights-based framing when not present in the passage.
Ability to extract the central message of a complex passage involving competing socio-economic and ecological priorities.
Trap: Option (d) acts as an emotional trap advocating for a total ban, while option (b) introduces out-of-scope constitutional concepts.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.