UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q2 · Comprehension
Maintaining an ecosystem just to conserve biodiversity will affect its commercial potential as well as the livelihoods dependent on the ecosystem. There is also a conflict between using an ecosystem only for livelihoods, for commercial exploitation, or strictly for conservation. Deforestation caused due to commercial exploitation will lead to indirect harm like floods, siltation problems and microclimatic instability, apart from adversely affecting livelihoods dependent on forests. These conflicts are particularly acute in developing countries where the dependence of people on the ecosystem is significant, and commercial exploitation has the potential to boost national income.
With reference to above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
I. No country needs to depend on ecosystems to boost national income.
II. Resource-rich countries need to share their resources with those of scant resources so as to prevent the degradation of ecosystems.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid ?
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Neither assumption is logically implied by or necessary for the arguments presented in the passage.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage explicitly states that commercial exploitation of ecosystems has the potential to boost national income, particularly in developing countries.
- Assuming that no country needs to depend on ecosystems to boost national income directly contradicts the premise established in the text.
- The passage discusses the trade-offs between conservation, commercial exploitation, and local livelihoods within an ecosystem.
- It makes no reference or implication regarding international resource sharing between resource-rich and resource-scant nations.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must accept as true for the conclusion or argument to hold validity.
- Valid assumptions must logically bridge the gap between the given premises and conclusions without introducing unmentioned external topics.
- Absolute generalizations using words like no country or never are generally invalid unless explicitly supported by the text.
- External real-world solutions that are not implied by the text scope must be treated as out-of-scope assumptions.
Related facts for revision
- Distinguishing implicit assumptions from explicit facts and logical inferences in passage analysis.
- Recognizing extreme language indicators like all, none, always, and never in CSAT verbal reasoning.
- Avoiding the trap of applying outside domain knowledge to pure reading comprehension passages.
Ability to identify necessary unstated assumptions while eliminating out-of-scope and contradictory statements.
Trap: Candidates often choose assumption II because global resource sharing sounds like a positive real-world environmental solution, ignoring that it is entirely absent from the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.