UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q42 · Comprehension
Over the next 30 years, many countries are promising to move to net-zero carbon, implying that household emissions will have to be cut to close to nothing. A leading climate scientist reckons that, at best, half the reduction might be achieved through demand-side measures, such as behavioural changes by individuals and households. And even that would require companies and governments to provide more incentives to change through supply-side investments to make low-carbon options cheaper and more widely available.
With reference to the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
I. Supply-side investments in companies can result in low-carbon behaviour in people.
II. People are not capable of adapting low-carbon behaviour without the involvement of Government and Companies.
Which of the above assumptions is/are valid?
- aI only
- bII only
- cBoth I and II
- dNeither I nor II
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Statement I is a valid assumption because the text explicitly connects supply-side investments to enabling low-carbon behavioral changes, whereas Statement II makes an unsubstantiated absolute claim about human capability.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage states that behavioral changes by individuals require companies and governments to provide incentives through supply-side investments to make low-carbon options cheaper and accessible.
- The author implicitly assumes that making low-carbon options cheaper and more available through supply-side investments will successfully lead to or result in low-carbon behavior among people.
- The passage notes that reaching half the emission target through behavioral changes requires supply-side incentives from governments and companies.
- Claiming that people are not capable of adapting low-carbon behavior at all without government and company involvement is an extreme generalization not assumed by the author.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must hold as true for the main argument to be logically sound.
- The Negation Test can be applied: if negating the assumption destroys the logical flow of the argument, the assumption is valid.
- Avoid accepting statements with extreme or absolute words such as not capable or impossible unless explicitly established by the context.
- Distinguish between what is practically required to achieve a large-scale target and an absolute assertion about individual capacity.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying implicit assumptions versus explicit inferences in reading comprehension passages.
- Detecting extreme qualifiers such as never, completely, solely, or impossible in CSAT options.
- Evaluating cause-and-effect policy arguments involving demand-side and supply-side dynamics.
Ability to identify sound logical assumptions without falling for extreme or overgeneralized assertions.
Trap: Candidates often select Option (c) assuming that because involvement is needed for the target, people are entirely incapable on their own.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.