EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT Q75 · Numeracy

Year2025
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ75
SubjectNumeracy

In a T20 cricket match, three players X, Y and Z scored a total of 37 runs. The ratio of number of runs scored by X to the number of runs scored by Y is equal to ratio of number of runs scored by Y to number of runs scored by Z.
Value-I = Runs scored by X
Value-II = Runs scored by Y
Value-III = Runs scored by Z
Which one of the following is correct ?

  1. aValue-I < Value-II < Value-III
  2. bValue-III < Value-II < Value-I
  3. cValue-I < Value-III < Value-II
  4. dCannot be determined due to insufficient data
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Cannot be determined due to insufficient data

Multiple valid integer combinations exist for X, Y, Z such as (9, 12, 16) and (16, 12, 9), making it impossible to uniquely determine the relative order of the three values.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • If X = 9, Y = 12, and Z = 16, then X:Y = 3:4 and Y:Z = 3:4, giving X + Y + Z = 37.
  • In this specific case, Value-I < Value-II < Value-III holds true.
  • However, this is not the only possible solution, so Option (a) cannot be uniquely asserted.
✗ Option (b)
  • If X = 16, Y = 12, and Z = 9, then X:Y = 4:3 and Y:Z = 4:3, giving X + Y + Z = 37.
  • In this specific case, Value-III < Value-II < Value-I holds true.
  • Because this reverse case is equally valid, Option (b) is also not uniquely true.
✗ Option (c)
  • The given ratio condition X/Y = Y/Z implies Y^2 = XZ, meaning Y is the geometric mean of X and Z.
  • For any two distinct positive numbers X and Z, their geometric mean Y must always lie strictly between X and Z.
  • Therefore, Z (Value-III) can never lie between X and Y, making Option (c) mathematically impossible.
✓ Option (d)
  • Let X/Y = Y/Z = a/b in lowest terms, so X = k * a^2, Y = k * a * b, and Z = k * b^2.
  • The sum X + Y + Z = k * (a^2 + ab + b^2) = 37. Since 37 is prime and runs are integers, k = 1 and a^2 + ab + b^2 = 37.
  • Integer solutions for (a, b) are (3, 4) and (4, 3), leading to (X, Y, Z) = (9, 12, 16) or (16, 12, 9). Since both X < Y < Z and Z < Y < X are valid, the correct relationship cannot be determined.

Concept to know

  • Continued Proportion: Three non-zero numbers X, Y, and Z are in continued proportion if X/Y = Y/Z, which implies Y^2 = XZ.
  • Representation of Terms: If X/Y = Y/Z = a/b, then X, Y, and Z can be written as a^2 * k, a * b * k, and b^2 * k respectively for some integer k.
  • Integer Constraints: Runs scored in a cricket match must be non-negative integers.
  • Diophantine Equation: Solving a^2 + ab + b^2 = 37 for integers yields (a, b) = (3, 4) or (4, 3) when k = 1.
  • Geometric Mean Property: In a sequence of positive numbers in continued proportion, the middle term Y always lies between the outer terms X and Z.

Related facts for revision

  • Properties of Geometric Progressions (GP) where consecutive terms have equal ratios.
  • Finding integer solutions for quadratic Diophantine equations.
  • Data Sufficiency problems involving symmetric variables.
  • Comparison of Arithmetic Mean (AM), Geometric Mean (GM), and Harmonic Mean (HM).
How UPSC tests this

Testing whether candidates check for multiple distinct integer solutions before concluding a unique order.

Trap: Stopping after finding the first valid set (9, 12, 16) and choosing option (a) without testing if the inverted set (16, 12, 9) also satisfies all conditions.

More Numeracy PYQs

All Numeracy questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.