UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q11 · Comprehension
Which of the following conclusions are valid?
I. Sport is more than just games; it is a way of life.
II. Sport can help mitigate the problems of seclusion among the young.
III. Earning laurels in sport can help one secure a job on the basis of an assigned quota.
IV. Standard corporate sector skills cannot be learnt through sport.
- a1 and 3 only
- b2 and 4 only
- c1, 2 and 4
- d1, 2 and 3
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage supports Statements 1, 2 and 3 (its 'not just medals or quota jobs' line accepts that quota jobs are one benefit of sport), while Statement 4 is contradicted by the skills the passage lists.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage closes by urging that sport should become a way of life.
- 'Sport is more than just games; it is a way of life' is almost a direct restatement of that line, so it is a valid conclusion.
- The passage says today's generation is struggling with depression and anxiety, and that inactive children rarely leave the house.
- Rarely leaving the house, along with the anxiety and depression that go with it, is seclusion. The author presents sport as a remedy for these problems.
- So 'sport can help mitigate the problems of seclusion among the young' follows from the passage.
- The passage says sport is not just about winning medals or getting jobs through a sports quota.
- 'Not just X but also Y' accepts X as true. The author does not deny that laurels in sport can fetch a quota-based job. The author only says sport offers much more than that.
- The statement claims only that this 'can help', which is exactly the benefit the passage acknowledges. It is therefore a valid conclusion, even though it is not the author's main emphasis.
- The passage explicitly lists time management, fitness, teamwork and coordination as things sport teaches.
- These are standard workplace and corporate skills, so saying they 'cannot be learnt through sport' contradicts the passage.
- Statement 4 is invalid. This eliminates options (b) and (c) immediately.
Concept to know
- A valid conclusion must be directly supported by the passage or follow necessarily from it. It must not contradict any line or need outside assumptions.
- In comprehension, a 'not just X' or 'not merely X' construction accepts X as true and adds a wider claim. It does not negate X.
- Map each statement to a specific line: a restatement or paraphrase is valid, a contradiction is invalid, and an unsupported extension is invalid.
- Paraphrase recognition matters: 'inactive children rarely leaving the house' is a paraphrase of seclusion. UPSC rarely repeats the passage's exact words.
- Check for absolute words such as 'cannot', 'always', 'only' and 'never'. A statement with such a word is invalid if the passage shows even one counter-instance.
- Use option elimination: find the clearly false statement first, strike out every option containing it, then test only the statement that separates the remaining options.
Related facts for revision
- Inference questions ('which can be inferred') are close cousins. The statement need not be stated outright, but it must follow logically from the passage.
- Assumption questions ask what the author takes for granted without stating it, which is different from what the author concludes.
- Main-idea or crux questions: here the crux is that sport is a holistic way of life. Statements 1 and 2 reflect it, while Statement 3 is a valid but secondary point.
- Watch for 'author's attitude' traps. A point the author treats as incomplete (quota jobs) is still accepted as true, unlike a point the author rejects outright.
- In multi-statement questions, the eliminated statement usually decides between two options. Here Statement 4 removes (b) and (c), and Statement 2 settles (a) versus (d).
Distinguishing valid conclusions from contradictions, especially reading 'not just X' as acknowledging X, and recognising paraphrases such as seclusion for children who stay indoors.
Trap: Many candidates reject Statement 3 because the author downplays quota jobs, which pushes them towards (c). But 'not just' concedes the point, and (c) also contains the clearly false Statement 4. Others drop Statement 2 because the word 'seclusion' is not in the passage, which leads them to (a). Time-saver: strike out Statement 4 first, which leaves only (a) and (d), then verify Statement 2.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.