UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q4 · Data Sufficiency
X is a collection of certain odd numbers whereas Y is a collection of certain even numbers. T consists of the numbers all of which are either from X or from Y. Is every number of T from Y?
I. The sum of any two numbers belonging to T is even.
II. If both p and q are picked from T, then (p − 1)q is even.
- aQuestion answerable using one statement alone, but not the other
- bQuestion answerable using either statement alone
- cQuestion answerable using both together, but not either alone
- dQuestion not answerable even using both statements
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Both statements are true whether T is all odd (from X) or all even (from Y), so even together they cannot tell us that every number of T is from Y.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I alone: odd + odd = even (e.g. 3 + 5 = 8) and even + even = even (e.g. 4 + 6 = 10). The sum condition holds for an all-odd T and for an all-even T, so it cannot decide.
- Statement II alone: take an all-odd T = {3, 5}. Then (3 − 1) × 5 = 10, which is even. Take an all-even T = {4, 6}. Then (4 − 1) × 6 = 18, which is also even. Both cases pass, so it cannot decide.
- Neither statement alone answers the question, so (a) is wrong.
- Option (b) needs each statement to settle the question independently.
- As shown under (a), neither statement settles it, so (b) is wrong.
- Combining the two statements leaves the same two possibilities: T = {3, 5} satisfies both, and so does T = {4, 6}.
- Under the first case the answer is No. Under the second case the answer is Yes.
- Two different answers remain, so the combination is insufficient and (c) is wrong.
- Each statement is a property of every same-parity set. At most it rules out a mixed odd-even T.
- Example of a mixed T failing Statement II: if T contained 4 and 3, then (4 − 1) × 3 = 9, which is odd.
- Both statements are compatible with T being from X and with T being from Y, so the question is not answerable even using both. Hence (d).
Concept to know
- Parity rules for sums: odd + odd = even, even + even = even, odd + even = odd. So 'every pair sums to even' only means all members share the same parity, not which parity.
- Parity rules for products: a product is even if at least one factor is even, and odd only if every factor is odd.
- For (p − 1)q: if p is odd, then p − 1 is even and the product is even. If q is even, the product is even. It is odd only when p is even and q is odd.
- Data sufficiency method: for each statement, find one example where the answer is Yes and one where it is No. If both exist, the statement is insufficient.
- Then test the combination with the same examples. If a single pair of cases satisfies both statements but gives opposite answers, choose 'not answerable even using both'.
- Always check whether a statement merely restates what the stem already guarantees. Such a statement adds no information.
Related facts for revision
- Parity variants of this question test expressions like p + q, pq, p² − q, (p + 1)(q + 1) or p − q. Reduce each to 'when is it odd?' before testing cases.
- Shortcut: if a condition is automatically true for both the Yes scenario and the No scenario, it is useless. Spot this in seconds by plugging in one small odd set and one small even set.
- Remainder-based variants ask for the remainder on division by 2, 3 or 4. They follow the same logic of checking whether a condition pins down the class or only the sameness of class.
- Yes/No data sufficiency questions: a statement is sufficient if it gives a definite No as well as a definite Yes. Insufficiency means both answers remain possible.
- Watch for 'any two' or 'both picked' wording. It applies to every pair, including the reversed order (p, q) and (q, p), which is often what eliminates mixed cases.
Number properties (parity of sums and products) combined with data sufficiency logic: separating a condition that fixes sameness of parity from one that fixes the actual parity.
Trap: Candidates see 'sum is even' or '(p − 1)q is even', link 'even' with Y, and pick (a) or (c). Both conditions hold equally for an all-odd set. Time-saver: test T = {3, 5} and T = {4, 6} against both statements; both pass, so mark (d) within a minute.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.