UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q2 · Data Sufficiency
For two distinct real numbers x and y, which of them is bigger?
I. x² < y < 1
II. y < √x < 1
- aQuestion answerable using one statement alone, but not the other
- bQuestion answerable using either statement alone
- cQuestion answerable using both together, but not either alone
- dQuestion not answerable even using both statements
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Even after combining both statements, x = 0.49 with y = 0.6 gives y > x, while x = 0.49 with y = 0.3 gives y < x, so the order cannot be fixed.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement I alone (x² < y < 1): take x = 0.5, so x² = 0.25 and y can be anywhere in (0.25, 1). y = 0.6 gives y > x, but y = 0.3 gives y < x, so it is insufficient.
- Statement II alone (y < √x < 1): √x must be real and less than 1, so 0 ≤ x < 1. Take x = 0.49, so √x = 0.7 and y < 0.7. y = 0.6 gives y > 0.49, but y = 0.4 gives y < 0.49, so it is insufficient.
- Neither statement works alone, so 'one alone but not the other' is wrong.
- This option needs each statement to be sufficient by itself.
- Both statements were shown insufficient individually with counter-examples (y = 0.6 versus y = 0.3 in I, and y = 0.6 versus y = 0.4 in II).
- So 'either statement alone' is ruled out.
- Combined, the conditions become 0 < x < 1 and x² < y < √x. For 0 < x < 1 the order is x² < x < √x, so x lies strictly inside the allowed range for y.
- Check with x = 0.49 (x² = 0.2401, √x = 0.7). y = 0.6 satisfies 0.2401 < 0.6 < 1 and 0.6 < 0.7 < 1, and here y > x. y = 0.3 satisfies 0.2401 < 0.3 < 1 and 0.3 < 0.7 < 1, and here y < x.
- Both orders remain possible even together, so the combined statements are not sufficient.
- I alone, II alone and I + II together all allow both y > x and y < x.
- The deciding step is that y may lie in (x², x) or in (x, √x). Both intervals are non-empty whenever 0 < x < 1.
- Therefore the question cannot be answered even using both statements.
Concept to know
- Data sufficiency asks whether the data fixes a unique answer, not what the answer is. A 'which is bigger' question is sufficient only if every allowed case gives the same order.
- Standard order of testing: check Statement I alone, then Statement II alone, and combine them only if both fail individually.
- To prove insufficiency, find two valid cases that satisfy the condition but give opposite answers. One such pair of counter-examples is enough.
- Key fraction fact: for 0 < x < 1, x² < x < √x < 1. Squaring makes a proper fraction smaller and taking the square root makes it larger.
- Domain check: √x is real only for x ≥ 0, so a statement containing √x quietly restricts x. Always extract such hidden conditions before testing.
- When combining inequalities, write the merged range for y (here x² < y < √x). Then ask whether the other variable lies inside or outside that range. If it lies inside, both orders are possible.
Related facts for revision
- Comparison variants such as 'Is x > x²?' or 'Is √x > x?' are decided entirely by whether x is in (0, 1), equal to 0 or 1, or greater than 1. Test values like 0.5, 2 and negative numbers.
- Number-picking shortcut: use convenient perfect squares such as x = 0.49, 0.25 or 0.64, so that √x and x² are easy to compute while testing cases.
- Negative values matter: in conditions like x² < y, x can be negative (x = -0.5 gives y > x always). Test both signs when the domain allows.
- Yes/No data sufficiency: a statement that always gives a definite 'No' is sufficient. Only a mixture of Yes and No makes it insufficient.
- Option-pattern recognition: in UPSC's four-option data sufficiency format, if the combined range of one variable strictly contains the other variable, the answer is usually (d).
Logical handling of inequalities with fractions, squares and square roots, and the discipline of using counter-examples in data sufficiency.
Trap: Option (c) tempts candidates because combining x² < y and y < √x looks like it 'traps' y near x, so they assume an order is fixed. In fact x lies inside (x², √x), so y can fall on either side. Time-saver: fix one value such as x = 0.49, then try two values of y (0.3 and 0.6) that satisfy everything. If the order flips, mark (d) immediately.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.