UPSC Prelims 2026 CSAT Q8 · Reasoning
The weight of X, in kg, is denoted by X. The weights of A, B, C, D, P, Q, R and S are measured. Given: A+B+C+D = 17; A+C = 6; P+Q+S+D = 15; P+Q+R+B = 17; P = R and Q = S. Which one of the following statements is correct?
- aB and D together weigh less than the total weight of P and Q.
- bP and Q together weigh more than the total weight of A and C.
- cP weighs more than Q.
- dQ weighs more than P.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Adding the two P-Q equations and substituting B + D = 11 gives P + Q = 7, which is more than A + C = 6.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- From A + B + C + D = 17 and A + C = 6, we get B + D = 17 − 6 = 11.
- From the working (see option b), P + Q = 7.
- The option claims 11 < 7, which is false. B and D together actually weigh more than P and Q.
- Substitute R = P and S = Q. Equation (iii) becomes P + 2Q + D = 15, and equation (iv) becomes 2P + Q + B = 17.
- Add them: 3P + 3Q + B + D = 32. Putting B + D = 11 gives 3(P + Q) = 21, so P + Q = 7.
- A + C = 6, and 7 > 6, so P and Q together do weigh more than A and C.
- Subtracting P + 2Q + D = 15 from 2P + Q + B = 17 gives P − Q = 2 − (B − D).
- B and D are known only as a sum (11), not individually, so B − D and therefore P − Q are unknown.
- For example, P = 4, Q = 3 and P = 3, Q = 4 both fit, so 'P > Q' cannot be concluded.
- By the same working, P − Q = 2 − (B − D), which depends on the unknown split of B and D.
- Only P + Q = 7 is fixed. Q could be more than, less than or equal to P.
- 'Q > P' is therefore not determinable from the data.
Concept to know
- This is a system of linear equations with more unknowns than equations. The goal is to find a combined value, not each variable separately.
- Use the given equalities (P = R, Q = S) first to cut down the number of distinct variables.
- Look for a combination of equations, usually addition or subtraction, that makes the target expression appear as a block, here 3(P + Q) + (B + D).
- Replace any already-known block (B + D = 11) as a single unit rather than trying to solve for B and D individually.
- When an option compares two individual variables whose difference depends on an unknown, that option is 'cannot be determined' and hence wrong.
- Always check whether the data fixes a sum or a difference. Sums can be compared with other sums, but individual ordering usually cannot be fixed.
Related facts for revision
- Pairwise-sum problems, such as A + B = x, B + C = y, C + A = z: add all three and halve to get A + B + C, then subtract to find each value.
- Underdetermined systems, for example 3 equations in 4 unknowns: UPSC asks which statement 'must be true'. Test options with two different valid number sets to eliminate them.
- Age and weight puzzles in which symmetric equations, when added, give a multiple of the target sum (as 3(P + Q) did here).
- 'Cannot be determined' traps: if an option needs an individual value and only sums are fixed, it is almost always the wrong choice.
- Shortcut: before solving anything, scan the options to see which expressions (P + Q, B + D, A + C) you need, then aim the algebra only at those.
Selective manipulation of linear equations: finding a required combined quantity without solving every variable, and recognising what cannot be determined.
Trap: Candidates who try to solve for P and Q individually get stuck. They may then guess (c) or (d), or misread the inequality in (a) because B + D and P + Q are both 'pair sums'. Time-saver: substitute R = P and S = Q, add equations (iii) and (iv) directly, and use B + D = 11. This gives P + Q = 7 in about 30 seconds.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.