UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q7 · Numeracy
A certain number of men can complete a piece of work in 6k days, where k is a natural number. By what percent should the number of men be increased so that the work can be completed in 5k days?
- a10%
- b(50/3)%
- c20%
- d25%
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Since total work is constant, the number of men required is inversely proportional to time, meaning reducing time from 6k to 5k days requires increasing men by 20%.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- A 10% increase in men makes the new manpower 1.1 times the original.
- The required time would become 6k / 1.1 = 5.45k days, which is not equal to 5k days.
- The value (50/3)% or 16.67% represents the percentage decrease in time from 6k to 5k days, calculated as (6k - 5k) / 6k × 100 = 16.67%.
- This is a common trap representing time reduction rather than the required percentage increase in men.
- Let initial men be M1 and new men be M2. Since Work = Men × Days, M1 × 6k = M2 × 5k.
- Simplifying gives M2 / M1 = 6 / 5, which means M2 is 1.2 times M1.
- Percentage increase in men = [(6 - 5) / 5] × 100 = 1/5 × 100 = 20%.
- A 25% increase in men makes the new manpower 1.25 times the original.
- The required time would become 6k / 1.25 = 4.8k days, which is less than 5k days.
Concept to know
- Total Work is given by the product of Number of Men (M) and Number of Days (D), assuming equal individual efficiency.
- When Total Work remains constant, M1 × D1 = M2 × D2, establishing an inverse proportional relationship between Men and Days.
- If time decreases in the ratio a:b (from 6k to 5k, ratio 6:5), the required manpower must increase in the inverse ratio b:a (5:6).
- The percentage increase in manpower is calculated with respect to the initial manpower base, represented as [(M2 - M1) / M1] × 100.
- The natural number variable 'k' acts as a common scaling factor and cancels out completely during ratio calculation.
Related facts for revision
- Multiplying efficiency or manpower by a factor affects completion time inversely, such as doubling men halving the required days.
- The generalized work formula M1 × D1 × H1 / W1 = M2 × D2 × H2 / W2 accounts for variations in daily working hours (H) and work quantity (W).
- Percentage change rule: a decrease of 1/x in one variable requires an increase of 1/(x-1) in the inversely proportional variable to keep the product constant.
- Questions combining men, women, and children use efficiency equivalence ratios to convert all workers into a unified standard unit.
Understanding inverse proportionality and avoiding base-value traps during ratio-to-percentage conversions in Time and Work problems.
Trap: Candidates often calculate the percentage decrease in days [(6k - 5k)/6k = 1/6 = (50/3)%] and mistakenly select Option (b) instead of calculating the percentage increase in men [(6 - 5)/5 = 1/5 = 20%].
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.