UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q61 · Comprehension
In a robust democracy, reality, howsoever inconvenient it may be, finds its expression both in the speech of political leaders and the other social forms of assertion. The existence of the real has to be transparent, both through its circulation in and by the media as well as its argumentative articulation in deliberative democracy. A normatively responsible media through its communication effect has the responsibility to circulate the content of reality without distortion.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crux of the above passage?
- aResponsible media should not distort the real in an ideal democracy.
- bFake news seems inherent in the life of an ideal democracy.
- cThere should not be any kind of restrictions on the freedom of expression in an ideal democracy.
- dIrresponsible media and political leaders cannot be effectively controlled in an ideal democracy.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage explicitly concludes that a normatively responsible media has the duty to circulate reality without distortion in a democracy.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The text directly concludes that a normatively responsible media has the responsibility to circulate the content of reality without distortion.
- This accurately captures the central message and obligation of media within a robust deliberative democracy.
- The passage calls for the transparent circulation of reality without distortion.
- It never states or implies that fake news is inherent or inevitable in an ideal democracy.
- The passage discusses the expression and communication of reality through speech and media.
- It does not address or advocate for the complete absence of any restrictions on freedom of expression.
- The passage emphasizes the responsibilities of media and political speech in a democracy.
- It makes no claim regarding whether irresponsible media or political leaders can or cannot be effectively controlled.
Concept to know
- Identify the core thesis by looking at the concluding sentence which explicitly defines the normative duty of media.
- Eliminate options that introduce extreme assertions such as cannot be controlled or inherent presence of fake news.
- Avoid outside knowledge or general socio-political theories that go beyond the text provided in the passage.
- Distinguish between what the author considers ideal responsibilities versus unmentioned policy restrictions.
Related facts for revision
- Crux and Main Idea questions in reading comprehension.
- Recognizing normative statements dealing with duty, ethics, and responsibilities.
- Identifying extreme qualifier words like any kind of, inherent, or cannot be.
- Fact-checking options directly against passage sentences.
Ability to extract the central message and normative conclusion from a short analytical passage.
Trap: Options like option c attract candidates because free speech is a familiar democratic ideal, even though the passage does not discuss restrictions.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.