UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q12 · Comprehension
Today, if we consider cities such as New York, London and Paris as some of the most iconic cities in the world, it is because plans carrying a heavy systems approach were imposed on their precincts. The backbone of the systems theory is the process of translating social, spatial and cultural desirables into mathematical models using computing, statistics, optimization and an algorithmic way of formulating and solving problems. The early universities of the West which began to train professionals in planning, spawned some of the most ingenious planners, who were experts in these domains. This was because these very subjects were absorbed into the planning curriculum that had its roots in the social sciences, geography and architecture. Planning in India, and its education differ from the West.
Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. India needs a new generation of urban professionals with knowledge relevant to modern urban practice.
2. Indian universities at present have no capacity or potential to impart training in systems approach.
Which of the assumptions given above is/are correct?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Assumption 1 logically underlies the author argument that modern urban planning requires systems approach training which Indian planning education currently lacks compared to the West, whereas Assumption 2 is an extreme statement not supported by the passage.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage highlights how iconic Western cities succeeded by integrating computing statistics and optimization into planning education.
- By contrasting this success with the fact that planning education in India differs from the West the author implicitly assumes that India needs urban professionals trained in relevant modern systems approaches.
- Hence Statement 1 is a sound and logical assumption embedded in the argument.
- The text merely states that planning education in India differs from that of the West.
- Claiming that Indian universities currently have no capacity or potential is an extreme generalization that goes far beyond what the text states or implies.
- Hence Statement 2 is incorrect as an assumption.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must hold as true to make their main argument logical.
- The Negation Test helps verify an assumption by checking if reversing the statement breaks the core logic of the author.
- Extreme qualifiers such as no capacity zero potential or completely impossible are usually red flags unless explicitly proven by the text.
- Differentiate clearly between an implicit assumption necessary for the text and an unsupported extreme claim.
- Focus on the primary intent of comparative passages which often suggest a need for reform without declaring total failure of local institutions.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying unstated assumptions versus explicit inferences in CSAT passages.
- Spotting extreme words like all none never or no capacity as common distractor traps.
- Evaluating comparative arguments where Western or foreign models are contrasted with Indian practices.
- Applying the negation technique to validate assumptions efficiently under time constraints.
Ability to identify necessary unstated assumptions while rejecting extreme or unsupported over-generalizations.
Trap: Candidates often choose Option c assuming that a difference in educational approach implies a complete lack of capacity or potential in Indian universities.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.