UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q31 · Comprehension
"The history of science is the real history of mankind." In this striking epigram, a nineteenth-century writer links science with its background. Like most epigrams, its power lies in emphasizing by contrast an aspect of truth which may be easily overlooked. In this case, it is easy to overlook the relations between science and mankind, and to treat the former as some abstract third party, which can sometimes be praised for its beneficial influences, but frequently and conveniently blamed for the horrors of war. Science and mankind cannot be divorced from time to time at men's convenience. Yet we have seen that, in spite of countless opportunities of improvement, the opening years of the present period of civilization have been dominated by international conflict. Is this the inevitable result of the progress of science or does the fault lie elsewhere?
Which of the following is/are emphatically conveyed by the author of the passage?
1. Without science, mankind could not have continued to exist till today.
2. It is the science that will ultimately determine the destiny of mankind.
Select the correct answer using the code given below.
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Neither statement is supported by the passage, as both make extreme claims that go beyond the author's explicit context.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The author emphasizes that the history of science is closely linked with human history, but never claims that mankind could not have survived without science.
- Asserting that human existence depended entirely on science is an extreme extrapolation not grounded in the passage.
- The passage ends with an open question about whether international conflicts stem from scientific progress or human failings elsewhere.
- It does not state or imply that science will ultimately determine the destiny of mankind, making this statement an unsupported over-generalization.
Concept to know
- Distinguish between explicit statements, logical inferences, and unstated extreme assumptions.
- Watch out for strong or deterministic qualifiers such as ultimately determine or could not have existed unless directly supported by the text.
- Recognize rhetorical questions as openings for reflection rather than definitive assertions of fact by the author.
- Avoid using external background knowledge or personal views about science while answering reading comprehension questions.
- Select options that strictly reflect what is emphatically conveyed by the passage without stretching the context.
Related facts for revision
- Identifying the core argument versus illustrative epigrams or rhetoric in CSAT passages.
- Differentiating between valid logical inferences and invalid extreme extrapolations.
- Eliminating options with absolute qualifiers like strictly, solely, entirely, or ultimately.
- Analyzing authorial tone when passages use historical quotes or open-ended concluding questions.
Critical reading comprehension skill to identify explicit authorial intent and avoid falling for extreme assertions.
Trap: Candidates often choose option (c) because the passage strongly connects science with human history, leading them to falsely assume that science dictates human survival and destiny.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.