UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q42 · Comprehension
Conventional classrooms, by emphasizing fixed duration over learning effectiveness, resign themselves to variable outcomes. The tyranny of the classroom is that every learner is subjected to the same set of lectures in the same way for the same duration. In the end, a few learners shine, some survive, and the rest are left behind. After the fixed duration, the classroom model moves on, with not a thought spared for those left behind. This is how we end up with 10 percent employability in our graduates after a decade and half of formal education. Repeating the same ineffectual script in the realm of skill education will not produce different results.
Based on the above passage, the following assumptions have been made :
1. As a large number of workers in our country are employed in unorganized sector, India does not need to change its present conventional classroom system of education.
2. Even with its present conventional classroom system of education, India produces sufficient number of skilled workers to fully realize the benefits of demographic dividend.
Which of the assumptions given above is/are valid?
- a1 only
- b2 only
- cBoth 1 and 2
- dNeither 1 nor 2
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Neither assumption is valid because statement 1 introduces unmentioned external concepts contradicted by the text, and statement 2 directly contradicts the passage's evidence of low employability.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage strongly criticizes the current conventional classroom system for producing only ten percent employability and warns against repeating this ineffectual script.
- The text makes no mention of the unorganized sector, nor does it assume or imply that the present system should remain unchanged.
- The passage explicitly states that after a decade and a half of formal education, the system achieves only ten percent employability among graduates.
- This low employability directly contradicts the assertion that India is producing a sufficient number of skilled workers to fully realize its demographic dividend.
Concept to know
- An assumption is an unstated premise that the author must accept as true in order to build the argument presented in the passage.
- The Negation Test can be used: if negating a statement weakens or destroys the passage's core argument, that statement is a valid assumption.
- Valid assumptions must remain strictly within the logical scope of the text and cannot contradict explicitly stated facts in the passage.
- External real-world knowledge must not be used to validate assumptions when answering CSAT reading comprehension questions.
- Critical key terms in the passage like tyranny, left behind, and ineffectual script indicate the author's stance against maintaining the status quo.
Related facts for revision
- Negation Technique for Assumptions: Reversing an option to see if the central logic of the passage collapses.
- Out-of-Scope Trap: Options that state true real-world facts (like unorganized sector dominance) but have no logical link to the author's premise.
- Factual Contradiction Trap: Options that make positive claims directly refuted by data in the passage (such as high skill generation vs ten percent employability).
Ability to evaluate implicit assumptions objectively using only the information and logical framework provided in the passage.
Trap: Candidates often choose Statement 1 because the unorganized sector is a well-known real-world Indian economic context, ignoring that it is absent from the passage.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.