UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q63 · Comprehension
Green growth involves rethinking growth strategies with regard to the impacts on environmental sustainability and the environmental resources available to poor and vulnerable groups. In rethinking growth, we need to focus on the current reality of a resource-constrained world. Resource intensive and, in particular energy intensive processes will need to make way for more efficient and resource frugal development strategies if we are to avoid an economic dead end or a world in which only a small elite is able to enjoy affluence in the midst of a sea of poverty.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crux of the above passage?
- aEnvironmental sustainability is inimical to our objective of achieving a high rate of GDP growth.
- bPoverty eradication is not possible without a rapid economic growth and the consequent environmental degradation.
- cMaintaining high environmental standards is now a prerequisite for a steady, sufficient and inclusive growth.
- dWith large populations, rampant poverty and limited resources of today's world, environmental degradation cannot be prevented and inequalities are inevitable.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that resource-frugal and environmentally sustainable strategies are essential to avoid economic dead ends and widespread poverty, making high environmental standards a prerequisite for steady, sufficient, and inclusive growth.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- This option states that environmental sustainability is inimical (harmful) to high GDP growth.
- The passage advocates for green growth rather than depicting environmental sustainability as an obstacle to economic success.
- It directly contradicts the passage's argument that sustainability prevents economic dead ends.
- This option asserts that poverty eradication requires rapid growth accompanied by environmental degradation.
- The passage explicitly warns against resource-intensive processes that worsen poverty and inequality.
- It argues for protecting resources relied upon by poor groups rather than accepting environmental destruction as necessary.
- The passage states that resource-frugal and efficient development strategies are necessary to avoid an economic dead end and elite-only affluence.
- Protecting environmental resources for poor and vulnerable groups ensures that growth remains socially inclusive and steady.
- Thus, maintaining high environmental standards is presented as an essential prerequisite for achieving steady and inclusive growth.
- This option presents a defeatist view that environmental degradation cannot be prevented and inequality is inevitable.
- The passage offers a constructive path forward by proposing a shift toward efficient and resource-frugal strategies.
- It aims to prevent widespread poverty rather than accepting it as inevitable.
Concept to know
- Identifying the crux of a passage requires synthesizing the core issue with the author's main proposed solution.
- Distinguish between fatalistic statements and the author's constructive recommendations.
- Eliminate options that present extreme views or directly contradict the passage's central premise.
- Focus on conditional statements where sustainable practices are described as necessary pre-conditions for long-term growth.
- Ensure the chosen option reflects both economic durability and social equity as emphasized in the passage.
Related facts for revision
- Crux and Main Idea Questions: Identify the single overall message that unifies the text.
- Assumption Questions: Determine unstated necessary premises required for the author's logic to hold.
- Inference Questions: Select logical deductions strictly supported by explicit statements without overgeneralizing.
- Tone Analysis: Differentiate between prescriptive/action-oriented passages and descriptive/analytical ones.
Ability to extract the central policy objective of a reading passage on sustainable development.
Trap: Option (d) acts as a fatalistic trap by listing realistic constraints mentioned in the passage but drawing an incorrect, hopeless conclusion that contradicts the author's proposed solution.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.