UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q70 · Data Sufficiency
A Question is given followed by two Statements I and II. Consider the Question and the Statements.
P, Q, R and S appeared in a test.
Question:
Has P scored more marks than Q?
Statement-I :
The sum of the marks scored by P and Q is equal to the sum of the marks scored by R and S.
Statement-II :
The sum of the marks scored by P and S is more than the sum of the marks scored by Q and R.
Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above Question and the Statements?
- aThe Question can be answered by using one of the Statements alone, but cannot be answered using the other Statement alone
- bThe Question can be answered by using either Statement alone
- cThe Question can be answered by using both the Statements together, but cannot be answered using either Statement alone
- dThe Question cannot be answered even by using both the Statements together
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Combining both statements yields P > R and S > Q, which allows for cases where P > Q as well as P < Q, so the question cannot be answered.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Statement-I alone gives P + Q = R + S, which provides no information about the relative magnitude of P compared to Q.
- Statement-II alone gives P + S > Q + R, which is insufficient on its own to determine if P > Q.
- Neither Statement-I alone nor Statement-II alone allows us to deduce whether P > Q.
- Hence, the question cannot be answered by using either statement alone.
- Adding Statement-I and Statement-II yields 2P + Q + S > 2R + Q + S, which simplifies to P > R.
- Subtracting Statement-II from Statement-I yields Q - S < S - Q, which simplifies to S > Q.
- Setting P = 10, Q = 5, R = 8, S = 7 satisfies both statements and gives P > Q (YES), while P = 5, Q = 10, R = 4, S = 11 also satisfies both statements and gives P < Q (NO), making both statements together insufficient.
- Because both YES and NO answers are possible even when using both statements together, the data provided is insufficient.
- Therefore, the question cannot be answered even by using both statements together.
Concept to know
- Data Sufficiency evaluates whether the given statements provide enough information to obtain a unique answer to the question.
- A question asking Has P scored more marks than Q requires a definitive YES or NO answer under all valid scenarios.
- Adding an equality A = B to an inequality C > D gives A + C > B + D.
- Subtracting an inequality C > D from an equality A = B reverses the inequality sign to give A - C < B - D.
- To prove insufficiency using combined statements, construct two counterexample sets of values that both satisfy all statements but yield opposite answers to the question.
Related facts for revision
- Linear inequalities and system of linear equations
- Data Sufficiency strategies for algebraic inequalities
- Testing sufficiency using plug-in numerical values
- Properties of real number inequalities under addition and subtraction
Algebraic manipulation of system of equations and inequalities, and testing uniqueness of solutions in Data Sufficiency.
Trap: Assuming that finding partial relations such as P > R and S > Q is sufficient to infer the relation between P and Q. Always plug in concrete numbers to verify if multiple outcomes exist.
More Data Sufficiency PYQs
All Data Sufficiency questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.