UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q13 · Comprehension
Not every voice on the internet commands the same kind of audience. When anonymous private entities with high capital can pay for more space for their opinions, they are effectively buying a louder voice. If political discourse in the digital sphere is a matter of outshining one's opponent till the election is won, then the quality of politics suffers. The focus of social media is restricted to the promotion of content that generates more user engagement, regardless of how inflammatory the content may be.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the central idea of the above passage?
- aConstructed as a marketplace of views, social media ensures instant access to information.
- bSocial media are not ideal or moral institutions but the products built by companies to make profits.
- cSocial media have been created to strengthen democracies.
- dIn today's world, social media are inevitable for well-informed social life.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights how social media platforms prioritize user engagement and paid space for high-capital entities over moral considerations or democratic quality, showing they act as profit-driven products.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage does not mention ensuring instant access to information as a positive feature.
- It highlights how capital buys reach and inflammatory content is promoted for engagement, which contradicts the idea of an ideal marketplace of views.
- The passage notes that capital allows entities to buy a louder voice and that platforms prioritize engagement regardless of inflammatory content.
- This directly implies that social media platforms prioritize commercial interests and user engagement over ideal democratic or moral values.
- The passage explicitly states that political discourse on these platforms causes the quality of politics to suffer.
- This contradicts the assertion that social media were created to strengthen democracies.
- The passage points out that engagement algorithms promote inflammatory content, which undermines a well-informed social life.
- The claim that social media are inevitable for a well-informed life is unsupported and contradicted by the context of misinformed political discourse.
Concept to know
- Identifying the central idea requires extracting the primary underlying theme that connects all individual arguments in the passage.
- Distinguish between explicit statements and implied conclusions derived from the author tone and critical stance.
- Recognize profit-versus-public-good themes in CSAT passages dealing with technology and digital media.
- Eliminate options that offer overly positive or optimistic claims when the passage maintains a critical tone.
- Focus on the main cause of the described issue rather than secondary observations or extreme extrapolations.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea vs Supporting Detail questions in CSAT Reading Comprehension.
- Author Tone Identification questions such as critical, analytical, neutral, or optimistic.
- Implicit Assumption questions where premises lead to an unstated foundational rule.
- Extrapolation traps where an option introduces unmentioned benefits or necessity.
Ability to synthesize the central argument of a passage that critiques digital media economics.
Trap: Option (a) and Option (d) introduce positive or general claims about access to information and necessity, which sound realistic in real life but are contradicted by the passage critical tone.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.