EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q58 · Reasoning

Year2024
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ58
SubjectReasoning

A Statement is given followed by two Conclusions numbered I and II. Consider the Statement and the Conclusions.
Statement :
India is the world's largest producer of milk.
Conclusion-I :
India is the world's largest exporter of milk.
Conclusion-II :
India does not import milk.
Which one of the following is correct?

  1. aOnly Conclusion-I follows
  2. bOnly Conclusion-II follows
  3. cBoth Conclusion-I and Conclusion-II follow
  4. dNeither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II follows
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(d) Neither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II follows

Being the largest producer of a commodity does not logically imply being the largest exporter or that no imports take place, as domestic consumption is unknown.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • Conclusion-I states India is the world's largest exporter of milk.
  • High production does not automatically lead to high exports because domestic consumption may absorb most or all of the produced milk.
  • Since trade data cannot be derived strictly from production data alone, Conclusion-I does not follow.
✗ Option (b)
  • Conclusion-II states India does not import milk.
  • Being the top producer does not rule out imports needed to cover localized shortages, demand for specific dairy products, or seasonal deficits.
  • Since the statement provides no information regarding import policies or quantities, Conclusion-II does not follow.
✗ Option (c)
  • This option requires both Conclusion-I and Conclusion-II to logically follow.
  • Both conclusions introduce external parameters regarding trade that are not supported by the premise in the statement.
  • Therefore, Option (c) is incorrect.
✓ Option (d)
  • Neither conclusion can be validly inferred solely from the given premise about production.
  • Statement-driven reasoning requires strictly limiting deductions to information given in or directly implied by the statement.
  • Hence, neither Conclusion-I nor Conclusion-II follows.

Concept to know

  • Statement-Conclusion problems in critical reasoning require strict adherence to the boundaries of the given statement.
  • Production, export, import, and domestic consumption are distinct variables that cannot be assumed equal or dependent without explicit premises.
  • A conclusion is valid only if it logically must follow under all possible scenarios consistent with the statement.
  • External general knowledge or real-world facts must not be used to validate conclusions in syllogistic logic.
  • Definite or extreme terms like largest exporter or does not import require explicit quantitative evidence in the premise.

Related facts for revision

  • Premise-Conclusion boundary rules in logical reasoning.
  • Differentiating between necessary logical implication and probable correlation.
  • Handling absolute terms such as always, never, all, none, and only in deductions.
  • Syllogisms involving trade metrics such as production versus consumption balances.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to evaluate logical validity strictly within the premises without introducing external real-world assumptions.

Trap: Candidates often assume high production automatically means high exports and zero imports, or bring in outside knowledge, leading them to pick option a, b, or c.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.