EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q11 · Comprehension

Year2024
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ11
SubjectComprehension

Today, if we consider cities such as New York, London and Paris as some of the most iconic cities in the world, it is because plans carrying a heavy systems approach were imposed on their precincts. The backbone of the systems theory is the process of translating social, spatial and cultural desirables into mathematical models using computing, statistics, optimization and an algorithmic way of formulating and solving problems. The early universities of the West which began to train professionals in planning, spawned some of the most ingenious planners, who were experts in these domains. This was because these very subjects were absorbed into the planning curriculum that had its roots in the social sciences, geography and architecture. Planning in India, and its education differ from the West.

Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the above passage?

  1. aCurriculum for urban planning courses should have diverse and interdisciplinary approach.
  2. bIn India, city administration is under bureaucracy which lacks formal training in urban planning and management.
  3. cIn India, the management of urban areas is a local affair with a chronic problem of insufficient funds.
  4. dWith high density of population and widespread poverty in our urban areas, planned development in them is very difficult.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) Curriculum for urban planning courses should have diverse and interdisciplinary approach.

The passage attributes the success of iconic Western cities to planning curricula that integrated social sciences, geography, architecture, statistics, computing, and optimization, implying that urban planning education needs a diverse and interdisciplinary approach.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Option (a)
  • The passage explicitly attributes the success of Western planners to a planning curriculum that absorbed diverse domains including social sciences, geography, architecture, computing, and statistics.
  • It notes that planning education in India differs from this Western model, logically inferring that Indian urban planning courses should adopt an interdisciplinary and diverse curriculum to achieve similar success.
✗ Option (b)
  • The passage mentions that planning education in India differs from the West, but it makes no mention of bureaucracy or administrative training deficiencies.
  • This option introduces outside information and assumptions not backed by the provided text.
✗ Option (c)
  • The text does not discuss local governance structures or chronic fund shortages in Indian urban areas.
  • This statement relies entirely on external real-world knowledge rather than logical inference from the passage.
✗ Option (d)
  • High population density and widespread poverty are nowhere mentioned or analyzed in the passage.
  • While factually true in real life, it is an out-of-passage extrapolation and thus incorrect as a passage-based inference.

Concept to know

  • Identify the main premise of the text, which highlights how integrating multidisciplinary subjects into Western urban planning curricula led to iconic, well-planned cities.
  • An inference must be directly derived from or strongly supported by the text without importing external facts or unstated premises.
  • The passage clearly links successful planning outcomes to a curriculum bridging social sciences, geography, architecture, computing, and mathematics.
  • By stating that planning education in India differs from the West, the author implicitly points toward reforming the curriculum as the logical solution.
  • In CSAT reading comprehension, eliminate options that bring in real-world facts not present in the text, such as bureaucracy, funds, or poverty.

Related facts for revision

  • Main idea summarizes stated points, whereas logical inference extends stated premises to their logical conclusion or underlying implication.
  • Authors often use comparative examples like West versus India to highlight a specific deficiency and suggest a course of correction.
  • Beware of options that state real-world truths but are completely absent from the given passage.
  • Use the scope check technique: if key terms in an option do not map to any line in the text, reject the option immediately.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to draw logical and rational inferences strictly bounded by the provided passage without relying on external real-world facts.

Trap: Options (b), (c), and (d) contain real-world facts about Indian urban issues, tempting candidates to choose them based on general knowledge rather than passage text.

More Comprehension PYQs

All Comprehension questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.