UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q62 · Comprehension
Now-a-days there is a growing trend to use interconnected home devices. As consumers increasingly network their homes, the connected home device manufacturers and service providers will seek to overcome “thin profit margins by gathering more of our personal data—with or without our agreement—turning the home into a corporate storefront”. Corporate marketers will have powerful incentives to observe consumer behaviour to understand the buying needs and preferences of the device owners.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the most logical, rational and practical message implied by the passage?
- aKnowledge of consumer behaviour leads to more capital expenditure in manufacturing sector.
- bKnowledge of consumer behaviour stimulates the growth of commerce and trade and thus helps in the overall economic development of the country.
- cInterconnected devices give a lot of comfort to home users and improve the overall quality of life.
- dInterconnected devices can be at security risk and home users may have privacy risk.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights that manufacturers gather personal data with or without user consent to offset thin margins, directly implying privacy and security risks.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage mentions manufacturers seeking to overcome thin profit margins by gathering data.
- It does not state or imply that knowing consumer behaviour leads to more capital expenditure in the manufacturing sector.
- While marketers track preferences to drive sales, linking this to overall economic development of the country overextends the text.
- This option ignores the critical tone of the passage regarding unauthorized data gathering.
- The text does not discuss user comfort or quality of life improvements provided by smart devices.
- It focuses entirely on data collection, thin profit margins, and corporate surveillance.
- The phrase gathering personal data with or without our agreement directly points to privacy risks for home users.
- Turning the home into a corporate storefront via interconnected network devices poses inherent security and privacy vulnerabilities.
Concept to know
- Focus on the main concern or warning highlighted by the author rather than secondary assumptions.
- Identify key trigger phrases such as gathering personal data with or without agreement to pinpoint the central theme.
- Eliminate options that make broad positive economic generalizations when the passage maintains a cautious or critical tone.
- Differentiate between explicit statements in the text and logical practical implications of technological adoption.
- Select the option that acts as a practical risk assessment directly justified by the passage text.
Related facts for revision
- Implication questions require deriving an unstated but directly logical consequence of the author's core premise.
- Assumption questions look for unstated foundational beliefs necessary for the argument to remain valid.
- Inference questions demand tight logical deductions that do not exceed the boundaries of the provided text.
- Main idea questions focus on summarizing the primary theme without adding outside knowledge.
Ability to identify the core critical message and risk implied in a passage while rejecting broad extrapolation traps.
Trap: Option (b) is a tempting trap that frames data collection as positive economic growth, ignoring the passage's explicit warning about privacy infringement.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.