EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q74 · Reasoning

Year2024
PaperCSAT
QuestionQ74
SubjectReasoning

A Main Statement is followed by four Statements labelled P, Q, R and S. Choose the ordered pair of the Statements where the first Statement implies the second, and the two Statements are logically consistent with the Main Statement.
Main Statement :
Pradeep becomes either a Director or a Producer.
Statement P : Pradeep is a Director.
Statement Q : Pradeep is a Producer.
Statement R : Pradeep is not a Director.
Statement S : Pradeep is not a Producer.
Select the correct answer.

  1. aSP only
  2. bRQ only
  3. cBoth SP and RQ
  4. dNeither SP nor RQ
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(c) Both SP and RQ

Since Pradeep must be either a Director or a Producer, negating one condition logically forces the other to be true, making both pairs SP (Not Producer implies Director) and RQ (Not Director implies Producer) valid.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✗ Option (a)
  • This option considers only the pair SP as valid.
  • While S (Pradeep is not a Producer) correctly implies P (Pradeep is a Director), it ignores the equally valid pair RQ.
  • Therefore selecting SP only is incomplete.
✗ Option (b)
  • This option considers only the pair RQ as valid.
  • While R (Pradeep is not a Director) correctly implies Q (Pradeep is a Producer), it ignores the equally valid pair SP.
  • Therefore selecting RQ only is incomplete.
✓ Option (c)
  • Pair SP: Statement S (Pradeep is not a Producer) logically implies Statement P (Pradeep is a Director) under the given either-or rule.
  • Pair RQ: Statement R (Pradeep is not a Director) logically implies Statement Q (Pradeep is a Producer) under the given either-or rule.
  • Since both ordered pairs SP and RQ are valid logical inferences consistent with the Main Statement, option (c) is correct.
✗ Option (d)
  • This option claims that neither pair is valid.
  • Since both SP and RQ directly follow the standard logical rules of a disjunctive statement, this option is incorrect.

Concept to know

  • In formal logic, a disjunctive statement of the form Either A or B means that at least one of the two alternatives must be true.
  • The fundamental rule of inference for disjunction is called Disjunctive Syllogism, which states that negating one alternative forces the truth of the other.
  • Symbolically, from Either A or B, if Not A is true, then B must follow (Not A implies B).
  • Similarly, from Either A or B, if Not B is true, then A must follow (Not B implies A).
  • An ordered pair XY means Statement X is the antecedent or premise and Statement Y is the consequent or conclusion such that X implies Y.

Related facts for revision

  • Conditional Statements: Statement If A then B (A implies B) is logically equivalent to its contrapositive Not B implies Not A.
  • Negation Rules: Negating a statement A gives Not A, which serves as the starting point for disjunctive syllogism.
  • Affirming a Disjunct Fallacy: Assuming that because A is true, B must be false is a logical fallacy unless the statement explicitly states an exclusive either-or.
  • Deductive Validity: An inference is valid if the conclusion cannot be false whenever the premise is assumed to be true.
How UPSC tests this

Ability to apply deductive logic rules to disjunctive (Either/Or) statements and identify valid logical implications.

Trap: Candidates often stop after identifying the first valid pair such as SP and pick option (a) without testing whether RQ is also valid.

More Reasoning PYQs

All Reasoning questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.