UPSC Prelims 2024 CSAT Q74 · Reasoning
A Main Statement is followed by four Statements labelled P, Q, R and S. Choose the ordered pair of the Statements where the first Statement implies the second, and the two Statements are logically consistent with the Main Statement.
Main Statement :
Pradeep becomes either a Director or a Producer.
Statement P : Pradeep is a Director.
Statement Q : Pradeep is a Producer.
Statement R : Pradeep is not a Director.
Statement S : Pradeep is not a Producer.
Select the correct answer.
- aSP only
- bRQ only
- cBoth SP and RQ
- dNeither SP nor RQ
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Since Pradeep must be either a Director or a Producer, negating one condition logically forces the other to be true, making both pairs SP (Not Producer implies Director) and RQ (Not Director implies Producer) valid.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- This option considers only the pair SP as valid.
- While S (Pradeep is not a Producer) correctly implies P (Pradeep is a Director), it ignores the equally valid pair RQ.
- Therefore selecting SP only is incomplete.
- This option considers only the pair RQ as valid.
- While R (Pradeep is not a Director) correctly implies Q (Pradeep is a Producer), it ignores the equally valid pair SP.
- Therefore selecting RQ only is incomplete.
- Pair SP: Statement S (Pradeep is not a Producer) logically implies Statement P (Pradeep is a Director) under the given either-or rule.
- Pair RQ: Statement R (Pradeep is not a Director) logically implies Statement Q (Pradeep is a Producer) under the given either-or rule.
- Since both ordered pairs SP and RQ are valid logical inferences consistent with the Main Statement, option (c) is correct.
- This option claims that neither pair is valid.
- Since both SP and RQ directly follow the standard logical rules of a disjunctive statement, this option is incorrect.
Concept to know
- In formal logic, a disjunctive statement of the form Either A or B means that at least one of the two alternatives must be true.
- The fundamental rule of inference for disjunction is called Disjunctive Syllogism, which states that negating one alternative forces the truth of the other.
- Symbolically, from Either A or B, if Not A is true, then B must follow (Not A implies B).
- Similarly, from Either A or B, if Not B is true, then A must follow (Not B implies A).
- An ordered pair XY means Statement X is the antecedent or premise and Statement Y is the consequent or conclusion such that X implies Y.
Related facts for revision
- Conditional Statements: Statement If A then B (A implies B) is logically equivalent to its contrapositive Not B implies Not A.
- Negation Rules: Negating a statement A gives Not A, which serves as the starting point for disjunctive syllogism.
- Affirming a Disjunct Fallacy: Assuming that because A is true, B must be false is a logical fallacy unless the statement explicitly states an exclusive either-or.
- Deductive Validity: An inference is valid if the conclusion cannot be false whenever the premise is assumed to be true.
Ability to apply deductive logic rules to disjunctive (Either/Or) statements and identify valid logical implications.
Trap: Candidates often stop after identifying the first valid pair such as SP and pick option (a) without testing whether RQ is also valid.
More Reasoning PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.